Jump to content

Starbreaker

Members
  • Posts

    1,303
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Starbreaker

  1. No, it's not from the article.

    I too have 'Vol 1', and the 3533 just sounds wrong. I checked this first, then went online to some tabs page.

    As for 3233, this sounds closer than 3533, but I think the 2 adds too much dissonance compared with 3x33.

    Maybe when JP launches his website, we can ask him? ;)

    I was just playing Immigrant song using the "3533" chord, and to my ear it sounds like it fits a bit better than "3233," I don't have perfect pitch or anything, but it sounds like it works to me (I'm not saying this is the answer though). :)

  2. Well, Page referes to it in the interview as an 'unusual G chord' :(

    The C9 was just according to the sheet music I have for Immigrant song.

    Now if Jimmy stated that it was an unusual G chord the C9 aka "3233" wouldn't make sense because there's no G note in that chord (the notes being C, E, B-flat, and D), whereas the notes in the so called "3533 chord" that was proposed earlier would make sense (The notes in that chord are C, G, B-flat, and D). I'm not sure what you would call this chord, but it is some form of G considering that all three notes of the G-Minor Triad are present (G, B-flat, and D).

  3. IMO, I think these eleven throw away songs grouped together would make a better LP than most other bands have released. I guess thats what makes Zeppelin the greatist.

    I wholeheartedly agree. Not everything Led Zeppelin created was great, but the majority of it was. And like you said, even their weaker songs (there aren't many) are better than anything most other bands could make.

    As for me, I'm not a fan of anything on In Through The Outdoor (just a personal opinion since I know there are a lot of people on these forums who like that LP). There are also some one-offs that I dislike, namely The Crunge.

×
×
  • Create New...