Jump to content

Colonial

Members
  • Posts

    26
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Profile Information

  • Location
    Victoria, British Columbia

Recent Profile Visitors

871 profile views
  1. For me it's a real toss-up. TSRTS has better sound overall. Robert's voice is post-Japan and he struggles as usual to get it into gear through Rock And Roll, which is just a disappointing way to start a show. There are however some killer versions on that album that stand up not just against HTWWW but well known and well loved boots. I love the DAC version, which has maybe the best "San Francisco" break. NQ as others have said is epic, and in my opinion just the right length. TSTRTS and TRS are fantastic. And the recently added tracks in the reissue are boss. But WLL sucks, as -- I will say -- it usually did live. HTWWW for its part has Robert's voice as it was on the original studio recordings for the most part. Jimmy I think is right to say that the band, musically and technically, were at their peak in 1972. There is little to complain about in terms of performance. It just doesn't quite have the relaxed feel of the MSG gig(s).
×
×
  • Create New...