Jump to content
Slate Blackcurrant Watermelon Strawberry Orange Banana Apple Emerald Chocolate Marble
Slate Blackcurrant Watermelon Strawberry Orange Banana Apple Emerald Chocolate Marble

Dirty Work

  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Dirty Work

  1. Dirty Work

    bass or guitar?

    Have you ever slapped a bitch? I mean, your bass. ?
  2. Dirty Work

    bass or guitar?

    I've never enjoyed any instrument I've played more than a bass guitar. Gotta have a decent drummer to play with though. And THAT, my friends, is FUN. Or play drums. 😜 Just don't let them turn you down and play loud.
  3. Dirty Work

    bass or guitar?

    I'm honestly the perfect example of "should I play bass or guitar". BASS. As someone who's done both, guitar gets old sometimes. Bass? It never gets old. And I've always had more fun playing a sweet bass line than going on a mountain climbing adventure trying to do some wild guitar solo, with hit or miss results. Play bass man. You could be an excellent guitarist, but in my opinion, you'll be HAPPY playing bass. And I think it is way funner. Plus, people are gonna want you. They'll NEED you.
  4. Dirty Work

    Redditch to erect a statue of John Bonham in his honour

    I've always thought that Jimmy was the songwriter, the magician if you will, Robert and Jonesy made Zeppelin sound unique, and sound tight, and Bonham gave Zeppelin their iconic sound. What's so cool about Zeppelin is that it wouldn't work without any of the members, unless in a perfectly ideal and luckily amazing reunion (with Bonzo's son). If the Concorde was still flying I could be there in 4-5 hours. Lol. So glad to see the man being honored and remembered. We wouldn't be here if it wasn't for him.
  5. Rain Song 3/19, agree, added to my list. Great balance of the instruments, and even thought many Rain Songs are good, Plant really goes above and beyond. 3/21 SIBLY, respectfully disagree, but I base this on the guitar solos only. Moby Dick, good call. Communication Breakdown, everyone says 2/13, but its not a best of Zeppelin 1975 anymore! Gimme Zeppelin! Is a must have, but not for a perfect '75 Zeppelin IMO. BUT... you're right about the full song, so... ok. Glad we share the same Over the Hills favorites. As we've done our listening, we know 3/5 is pretty damn cool an unique. 3/20 is also on my list, and it almost made my number one choice. Theres a part where Jonesy does a funky heavy metal groove and the rest play along. Love him on bass.
  6. I know what you mean and where you're coming from, and I'm usually in the same boat as you when it comes to other bands/new bands. Just think that if I can listen to GVF without turning it off immediately, they're not bad. I'm pretty picky, and I've listened to them and enjoyed a handful of times. But, they'll be history unless the songwriting gets better. The sound and style is just right though. They're not trying to be original, they happen to have a singer that sounds like Plant, so I think they made the right choice writing Zeppelin-inspired songs, otherwise we would never have heard of them.
  7. Ok here it is. Some I intentionally left blank, because after so much listening I couldn't come to an answer. For Dazed I'd say 3/21, and splice in the beginning of Dazed from 3/19 or 3/20 (since the sound quality and levels are the same) when Pagey's (slightly) out of tune. The Rain Song? Your guess... I'd listen more for the mellotron being in tune, but I didn't hear a bad one. They had that song pretty solid. Seems like 3/19 and 2/28 were good. Moby Dick, I can't tell, lets let a drummer decide on that one. Rock and Roll - 3/21 Sick Again - 3/21 Over the Hills and Far Away - 3/19 (or 3/20, 2/13 is good, not the best sound quality) In My Time of Dying - 3/21 (or 3/20, or 2/28, latter is HOT but feels rushed) Since I’ve Been Loving You - 2/14 (IMO, think this spot works better than after NQ, slows things down) The Song Remains the Same 3/3 The Rain Song - Kashmir - 3/21 (2/14 honorable mention and all instruments are evenly balanced, 2/28 runner up) No Quarter - 2/28 (use a latter ’75 NQ w/ faster solo for a bonus track) Trampled Under Foot - 2/12 (or 2/14. I found 3/5 to be a pretty cool, but sloppy, version FWIW.) Moby Dick - Dazed and Confused - Stairway to Heaven - 3/21 Whole Lotta Love - 3/21 Black Dog - 3/21 Communication Breakdown - 3/21 Heartbreaker - 3/21 *No Quarter (later ’75 version) - (bonus track) ? My list before 3/21's soundboard came out was good too, don't get me wrong. Hope I still have it. Hope you like!
  8. Done a great deal of listening to determine the best 1975 "show" using the best songs from each of the available soundboards, and I think you'll agree that its a pretty good list. I'll post it shortly when I get home!
  9. Dirty Work

    Best No Quarter from '75 US Tour

  10. Dirty Work

    Winston Remasters list

    Why do you post that you care? Do you think we care? We don't. Tired of the internet being filled with people like you. Go bully or take your anger out on your wife or something.
  11. Dirty Work

    living loving wreck on remastered vinyl led zeppelin 2

    Only one way to find out! (Fills up pitcher of water)
  12. Dirty Work

    3/12 best show of 1975?

    I don't know how I've overlooked this one, Millard recording and the 3 source mix I have sound great, but damn! This has to be my favorite 1975 performance. They come out the gates on a mission! Phew! Just listen to Sick Again, through No Quarter, and when Jimmy gets off on the fat riff of the final solo in No Quarter, and he sounds like '72 Jimmy there for a minute.
  13. Dirty Work

    Southampton '73 Multitrack

    Such a shame Robert is in bad shape during this gig. To me its probably my favorite sounding Zeppelin bootleg. It sounds like a raw live studio set, from beginning to end. Love the sound of this and the Long Beach '72 raw multi's on Studio Dazed. I imagine they would sound similar to standing on stage with the band. And Bonhams drum sound on Studio Daze Long Beach '72 is nuts. Recordings do these a lot of good. There are high points of Southampton but for the most part, it reminds me of Robert's 7/17/77 performance. Jimmy not so much a problem.
  14. Dirty Work

    March 21st 1975 Matrix

    Its a good effort, but I think this project could use a version 2.0 from the maker of this matrix. IDK who made it, they came close, but I think they should run back through it, sync the audio a tiny bit more, maybe reduce the amount of audience recording 25%, and pan the soundboard slightly right and the audience recording a tiny bit more than that to the left. It does sound flangey, but all the good matrixes only have a touch of audience recording. They're nowhere near 50/50% sbd/aud. Not the good ones. Just hoping this guy gives it a little more time bc honestly it could come out REALLY good. I give it a 7/10 at the moment, only because the flanging sound. Just being honest, if I knew how to do these well I'd do them too... So basically, to whoever made this matrix, give it a couple months of work then release version 2.0. You might be surprised how popular that matrix could become. Just a little less audience tape. IMO.
  15. Dirty Work

    Immigrant Song Ending Chord

    Jimmy is a freaking beast <3
  16. Dirty Work

    Robert Plant's Wedding Gift to Phil Collins Up for Auction

    Who is Phil Collins
  17. Dirty Work

    New Mystery Soundboard?

    No 3/17 on the new release isn't an upgrade. Just get DADGAD's 3/17 soundboard version
  18. Dirty Work


    2/28/75 gets one of my votes, but not my only vote. I get multiple votes.
  19. Dirty Work

    After 3/21/75. . Whats next??

    Whats left? Potentially everything from late 1970-1971 to 1977. Anything later is anyones guess.
  20. Dirty Work

    After 3/21/75. . Whats next??

    BS. They have at least all of 1975 and 1977. Its not what EVSD has, its what the person supplying EVSD has. The point is, setting these old legendary recordings is not something you can object to. Liberating a recording of such quality as 3/21/75 soundboard is NOT a sin. Idc who you are, it benefits everybody.
  21. Dirty Work

    New Mystery Soundboard?

  22. Dirty Work

    New Mystery Soundboard?

    It's so good it's almost hard to write a review about. This is the best soundboard of the soundboard revolution.
  23. Dirty Work

    New Mystery Soundboard?

    Here's my review of the 3/21/75 soundboard. ive got nothing. There is nothing to say about this release except it is solid all the way through and is as good as any official audio or video the band has released officially. If the band doesn't care about this boot, I'd understand, because they could copy it and release it officially and make 8 times as much as EVSD did. True story.
  24. Dirty Work

    New Mystery Soundboard?

    Let's get real folks. How do you think EVSD ended up with a soundboard of 3/21? It's called not taking care of your recordings and someone decides to snatch them. Then holds onto them and sells them. 1973 audience recordings sound like 73 boards. But lacking high end. 1975 audience recordings sound like 1975 soundboards with a PA and audience. 1977 audience recordings sound like 1977 soundboards through a PA with an audience, with some sounding flat. I believe they were stolen. But if stealing results in the live recordings being released to the fans, nothing wrong with that. Maybe something wrong with them profiting off it, yes, but for real... music is like a car's engine. An engine is meant to run. A recording is meant to be heard. This is called Trampled Underfoot. Ba dom da dom da doo doo doo doo da da