Jump to content

Marmalade_Skies

Members
  • Posts

    56
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Marmalade_Skies

  1. They're almost always mentioned in the top 2 or 3.  Jimi Hendrix was incredibly talented.  Has a blues/jazz/improv way of playing that was very akin to the black artists of the 30's-50's.  He was just really soulful and poetic with the guitar.  But unfortunately, he died way too young, and I don't think his catalogue matches up with Page's for that reason alone.  Page proved to be far more versatile and wide-reaching with the kind of music he'd play, between loud, soft, soothing, aggressive, he mastered just about every angle of guitaring.

  2. David Bowie's legacy is profound.  The man was always consistent, constantly changed and evolved his look/sound to push music in a new direction and rarely if ever faltered.  40 years into his career, he released an album that was every bit as great as his earlier material.  Think about this for a second.  Can any other musician claim these levels of accomplishment?  Zeppelin and Beatles got inertia after 10 years.  Most classic artists retire into performing their old material or they just release lots of really similar works that lack the impact of their earlier works.  Bowie, on his death bed, cranked out one of the very best albums of this emerging decade and sent shockwaves throughout the industry.

  3. Rolling Stones were really prolific.  Probably 60-70% of their songs were forgettable, but they've amassed at least 40 great songs by persistence, which is nonetheless an accomplishment.  Their 2 90's albums had some very nice tracks on it, they should have quit after that though.

  4. Geddy Lee is an amazing bassist, but only an average vocalist.  Neil Peart was an absolute beast (top 3 drummer of all time material).  Lifeson is a great guitarist too.  I love the rebellious experimental sci-fi type of sound they have.  If Rush could've had a 4th member who could really sing, they'd probably be on par with The Who and such.

  5. One of my favorite bands of all time.  Jim, of course, was a great poet, intelligent, pretentious, loveable, drunk, chaotic, ego maniac.  Their songs had an atmospheric poetry to them which made them unique from any other band, and even at their tail end, they tapped into a really good bluesy sound.  Also, Ray Manzarek, playing keys and bass at the same time, cannot be understated.  He was every bit as important as Jim.

  6. Nirvana was one of the great modern rock bands.  They smashed the mainstream at record levels with Nevermind, but totally challenged their fanbase with their final release In Utero.  There's just nothing like Kurt's wailing vocals.

    It's a real shame Kurt Cobain was in such poor health.  If he had lived, they could have released 3 or 4 more classic albums and maybe could have been top 10 of all time material.

  7. Paul McCartney is one of the best songwriters.  Great at coming up with melodies.  He's talented at a number of instruments from bass, to guitar, to drums, to piano and.  He's a strong lyricist, has great concepts in mind and while his vocals aren't amazing from a technical perspective, he can hit the notes he needs to.  He's a jack of all trades, and may be the most well rounded musician of all time.  He generally has made safe marketable songs, but on occasion he has made really progressive songs like Eleanor Rigby, Hey Jude and Helter Skelter.

  8. Pink Floyd was a very progressive band.  They excelled with making conceptual songs/albums, very atmospheric abstract-ish material.  Their stuff has been beautiful, bizarre, comical and haunting in equal parts.  I admire both their talent and the tenacity they had to be different than most mainstream bands.

  9. John Lennon was one of the best songwriters in history.  He didn't have Page's guitar skills or Plant's pipes, but he was more than just a musician.  He was the head, the cerebral force and the essential lyricist amongst The Beatles.  He was a visionary who constantly pushed forward progressive music, spearheading the industry's most popular trends and challenging it at the same time.  He was full of many different ideas and concepts.  Almost no two songs were the same.  He was able to churn out radio-friendly hits, experimental psychadelic songs and abrasive punchy songs in equal parts.  He's what you get if you combined Bob Dylan and Chuck Berry.  No one has been able to put out songs like "Imagine" and "Give Peace A Chance", which became secondary anthems and sent shockwaves throughout the world.

  10. Perhaps the only band with a catalogue that can match Zeppelin's.

    My top 25 Beatles Songs.

    1. While My Guitar Gently Weeps
    2. Something
    3. Across the Universe
    4. Here Comes The Sun
    5. In My Life
    6. Help!
    7. Two of Us
    8. Eleanor Rigby
    9. Strawberry Fields Forever
    10. I Am The Walrus
    11. With A Little Help From My Friends
    12. Dear Prudence
    13. Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds
    14. Happiness Is A Warm Gun
    15. Helter Skelter
    16. Yesterday
    17. Octopus' Garden
    18. She's Leaving Home
    19. For No One
    20. Back in the U.S.S.R.
    21. I Me Mine
    22. I Want You (She's So Heavy)
    23. Blue Jay Way
    24. Hello Goodbye
    25. Tomorrow Never Knows
  11. Just a quick tentative ranking list.  I'm probably going edit this list.  The top 5 are all amazing albums.  Are essentially tied.  The band's last 3 albums were inconsistent in quality.

    1. Led Zeppelin III
    2. Led Zeppelin IV
    3. Led Zeppelin I
    4. Led Zeppelin II
    5. Physical Graffiti
    6. Houses of the Holy
    7. Presence
    8. In Through the Out Door
    9. Coda
×
×
  • Create New...