ledded1 Posted June 15, 2008 Share Posted June 15, 2008 I made two simple points, namely that it wasn't hard to understand how she could have thought you had her post in mind, and that she never did suggest you should leave the boards. No reply here to either point. Your reaction to SC just seemed strangely harsh to me. And I didn't use the word 'clique' here at all, so why bring it up? So I assume that SC told you she didn't mean I should leave the board. She read into my post about others because she recognised what i meant by Plant bashing which she has done. She can't argue with that. So I make my point about the bashing and she takes it that it was directed soley at her. Not so this time. It is not strangely harsh, its firm, its an opinion not an attack ( quoted by SC herself in attacking me in a thread) She and I have been disagreeing about RPs solo career since he intimated that he he didnt want to tour with Zep. SC's not entirely innocent in her opinions Otto as I said and please don't be too naive that she doesn't post not so nice things herself at times. But we are adults and can deal with it. My reaction is one of frustration with people who say they love the band and band members and then continue their attacks upon one in particular because they feel he should be true only to Zep. I take a differnent view on this and then when a different view is put forward ( not only mine) it is attacked by the very people who then go crying to others that they are being got at. The RP bashing is a stain on this forum as far as i am concerned and there are a few people who sustain it. They aren't opinions they are just personal attacks on him. They are not worthy of the board in my view. Differing opinions and views are fine, we will all disagree at some point but the record never changes with some. And as a result neither does mine. SC has stated her case to me personally in the past and i have stated mine to her. we probably will never agree on this point and thats fine but please don't expect me to sit idly by if i disagree with someone. I know you don't and haven't and neither does SC. I have no problem with it. But i won't be manipulated into believeing someone is innocent. harsh words have been directed at others from her side but we don't need to drag that up again. The clique thing is an example of what's gone before when we have disagreed and there has been hypocricy in this area when I have defended someones stance and been accused of being in a clique and yet when others do it, its not a clique. Thankfully this isn't the case much now but i brought it up anyway to make a point. Anyway its 2.15 am here now and I need my beauty sleep ( believe me) so if this continues tomorrow or later today whichever it is, thats ok its just that i wont be responding for a few hours. Have a good night yourself Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.