Jump to content
Slate Blackcurrant Watermelon Strawberry Orange Banana Apple Emerald Chocolate Marble
Slate Blackcurrant Watermelon Strawberry Orange Banana Apple Emerald Chocolate Marble
Sign in to follow this  
kashmiran

Dream live album (imagine...)

Recommended Posts

Imagine: You've just won a contest to have Jimmy Page make you your own live album with your supervision. Any tracks from any date, any venue. What would your live album be. (Try to keep it to 3 or 4 discs max and in something of a realistic setlist ordering.) Here's mine:

Disc 1:

1. Rock and Roll (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

2. The Rover/Sick Again (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

3. Over the Hills and Far Away (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

4. The Song Remains the Same (January 22, 1973 - Southampton University, England)

5. The Rain Song (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

6. Kashmir (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

7. Since I've Been Loving You (July 7, 1980 - Berlin, Germany)

8. No Quarter (Mix between April 27, 1977 & March 19, 1975 - Cleveland, Ohio & Vancouver, Canada)

9. Communication Breakdown (August 11, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

Disc 2:

1. Ten Years Gone (April 28, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

2. Trampled Under Foot (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

3. That's the Way (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

4. Going to California (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

5. The Battle of Evermore (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

6. Out on the Tiles/Moby Dick (Mix between April 28, 1977 & March 20, 1975 - Cleveland, Ohio & Vancouver, Canada)

Disc 3:

1. Achilles Last Stand (August 11, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

2. Dazed and Confused (Mix between March 19 & 20, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

3. Stairway to Heaven (Mix between May 24 & 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

4. Whole Lotta Love (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

5. The Crunge/Theremin Solo (May 23, 1975 - Earl's Court)

6. Black Dog (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

As you can see, I favor the latter years more. I actually like the earlier years better, but they have been represented well enough, I think. Communication Breakdown is on disc 1, not disc 3, because it wouldn't fit on disc 3 with all those other songs on there.

;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

that would be so cool if i could do that. i just dont fell like posting all that now lol

Edited by jimmy page66

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yea, this thread is going to get ridiculous. pretty soon theres going to be a million posts of different 4 disc sets with all the same songs on it from a million people,

and ultimatley, its going to be impossible to read.

anyways, a concert is a whole experience, not just a bunch of songs all put together. the flow, feel, and energy of the concert as a whole will be comprimised if you mix and match shows.

me? im working on building a time machine to go back to 1971.04.01 (aka BBC Sessions, disc 2). plant sounded like a god damn banshee for the whole set. honestly.. have you heard a better set (as a whole)? there arent many.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
yea, this thread is going to get ridiculous. pretty soon theres going to be a million posts of different 4 disc sets with all the same songs on it from a million people,

and ultimatley, its going to be impossible to read.

anyways, a concert is a whole experience, not just a bunch of songs all put together. the flow, feel, and energy of the concert as a whole will be comprimised if you mix and match shows.

me? im working on building a time machine to go back to 1971.04.01 (aka BBC Sessions, disc 2). plant sounded like a god damn banshee for the whole set. honestly.. have you heard a better set (as a whole)? there arent many.

Actually, the thread might not get that long. You're the first reply this thread has gooten for quite some time since I posted it. And as far as continuity and flow between songs, I tried to pick mostly songs from similar concerts for my set. You may notice, also, that 70% of the material came from '75, and 70% of that material came from one show (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

Also, no. I have not heard a better set except maybe HTWWW.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
im working on building a time machine to go back to 1971.04.01 (aka BBC Sessions, disc 2). plant sounded like a god damn banshee for the whole set. honestly.. have you heard a better set (as a whole)? there arent many.

Can I buy a ticket for that time machine? Seriously... BBC Sessions floored me the first time I heard them. Ooooo my head! B)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MINE

Disc 1 1969-1972

1. The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

2. Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3. How Many More Times (March 1969 Lost Performances)

4. Dazed And Confused (March 1969 Super Show)

5. We're Gonna Groove (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

6. I Can’t Quit You (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

7. Dazed And Confused (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

8. What is and What Should Never Be (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

9. White Summer (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

10 .Moby Dick (Royal Albert Hall 1970)

11. C’mon Everybody/Something Else (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

12. Long Tall Sally (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

13. Heartbreaker (March 7,1970- Montreux)

14. Thank You (March 7,1970- Montreux)

15. Immigrant Song (June 27, 1972- Long beach)

16. Heartbreaker (June 25, 1972 - LA Forum)

17. Louie Louie (June 25, 1972 - LA Forum)

Disc 2 1973-1975

1. Celebration Day (July 27, 1973- MSG)

2. Black Dog (July 28 & 29, 1973- MSG)

3. Misty Mountain Hop (July 27 & 29, 1973 - MSG)

4.Since I've Been Loving You (July 29, 1973 - MSG)

5. No Quarter (July 27 & 28, 1973- MSG)

6. Dazed And Confused (July 27 & 29, 1973- MSG)

7. Stairway To Heaven (July 27 & 28 & 29, 1973- MSG)

8. The Ocean (July 27 & 29, 1973- MSG)

9. The Song Remains The Same (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

10. In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

11. Kashmir (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

12. Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

13. Trampled Under Foot (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

14. Dazed and Confused (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

15. Stairway To Heaven (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

16. Heartbreaker (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

17. Communication Breakdown (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

Disc 3 1977 &1980

1. The Song Remains The Same (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

2. Nobody's Fault But Mine (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

3. No Quarter (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

4. The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

5. Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

6. White Summer (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

7. Kashmir (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

8. Heartbreaker ( June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

9. Achilles Last Stand ( June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

10. Over The Top ( June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

11. Stairway To Heaven (June 23, 1977 - LA forum)

11. Whole Lotta Love/Rock And Roll ( June 23, 1977 - LA forum)

12. It’ll Be Me ( June 26, 1977 - LA forum)

13. Achilles Last Stand (July 17, 1977 - Seattle)

14. Stairway To Heaven (July 17, 1977 - Seattle)

15.Train Kept A Rollin' (June 29, 1980 - Zurich)

16. Trampled Under Foot (June 21, 1980 -Rotterdam)

Disc 4 1979

1. Black Dog (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

2. Over The Hills And Far Away (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

3. Misty Mountain Hop (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

4. No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

5. Ten Years Gone (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

6. Hot Dog (August 11, 1979 Knebworth)

7. The Rain Song (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8. Kashmir (August 4 & 11, 1979 Knebworth)

9. White Summer (August 4 & 11, 1979 Knebworth)

10. Trampled Underfoot (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

11. Sick Again (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

12. Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

13. In The Evening (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

14. Stairway To Heaven (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

15. Rock And Roll (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

16. Heartbreaker (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

17. Communication Breakdown (August 11, 1979 Knebworth)

Edited by jimmy page66

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you do realize that is 67 songs....

Edited by docron

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MINE

Disc 1 1969-1972

1. The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

2. Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3. How Many More Times (March 1969 Lost Performances)

4. Dazed And Confused (March 1969 Super Show)

5. We're Gonna Groove (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

6. I Can’t Quit You (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

7. Dazed And Confused (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

8. What is and What Should Never Be (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

9. White Summer (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

10 .Moby Dick (Royal Albert Hall 1970)

11. C’mon Everybody/Something Else (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

12. Long Tall Sally (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

13. Heartbreaker (March 7,1970- Montreux)

14. Thank You (March 7,1970- Montreux)

15. Immigrant Song (June 27, 1972- Long beach)

Disc 2 1973-1975

1. Celebration Day (July 27, 1973- MSG)

2. Black Dog (July 28 & 29, 1973- MSG)

3. Misty Mountain Hop (July 27 & 29, 1973 - MSG)

4.Since I've Been Loving You (July 29, 1973 - MSG)

5. No Quarter (July 27 & 28, 1973- MSG)

6. Dazed And Confused (July 27 & 29, 1973- MSG)

7. Stairway To Heaven (July 27 & 28 & 29, 1973- MSG)

8. The Ocean (July 27 & 29, 1973- MSG)

9. The Song Remains The Same (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

10. In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

11. Kashmir (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

12. Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

13. Trampled Under Foot (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

14. Dazed and Confused (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

15. Stairway To Heaven (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

16. Heartbreaker (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

17. Communication Breakdown (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

Disc 3 1977 &1980

1. The Song Remains The Same (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

2. Nobody's Fault But Mine (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

3. No Quarter (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

4. The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

5. Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

6. White Summer (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

7. Kashmir (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

8. Heartbreaker ( June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

9. Achilles Last Stand ( June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

10. Over The Top ( June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

11. Stairway To Heaven (June 23, 1977 - LA forum)

11. Whole Lotta Love/Rock And Roll ( June 23, 1977 - LA forum)

12. It’ll Be Me ( June 26, 1977 - LA forum)

13. Achilles Last Stand (July 17, 1977 - Seattle)

14. Stairway To Heaven (July 17, 1977 - Seattle)

15.Train Kept A Rollin' (June 29, 1980 - Zurich)

16. Trampled Under Foot (June 21, 1980 -Rotterdam)

Disc 4 1979

1. Black Dog (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

2. Over The Hills And Far Away (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

3. Misty Mountain Hop (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

4. No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

5. Ten Years Gone (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

6. Hot Dog (August 11, 1979 Knebworth)

7. The Rain Song (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8. Kashmir (August 4 & 11, 1979 Knebworth)

9. White Summer (August 4 & 11, 1979 Knebworth)

10. Trampled Underfoot (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

11. Sick Again (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

12. Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

13. In The Evening (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

14. Stairway To Heaven (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

15. Rock And Roll (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

16. Heartbreaker (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

17. Communication Breakdown (August 11, 1979 Knebworth)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why dream? Just make one like I did a few months ago using about 90% soundboard stuff:

Disc 1 (1969-71)

1. Train Kept A Rollin, 8-31-69 Dallas

2. Heartbreaker, 10-10-69 Paris

3. ALAIHY, 4-27-69 San Fran

4. We're Gonna Groove, 3-7-70 Montreux

5. SIBLY, 3-21-70 Vancouver

6. Celebration Day, 9-9-71 Hampton, VA

7. WIAWSNB, 8-31-71 Orlando

8. Dazed & Confused, 8-31-71 Orlando

9. Thank You, 4-1-71 London BBC

Disc 2 (1972-73)

1. Immigrant Song, 12-8-72 Manchester

2. OTHFA, 3-24-73 Offenberg

3. Dancing Days, 1-22-73 Southampton

4. TSRTS, 3-22-73 Essen

5. The Rain Song, 3-22-73 Essen

6. Misty Mountain Hop, 5-31-73 LA

7. SIBLY, 5-31-73 LA

8. Heartbreaker, 7-13-73 Detroit

9. WLL, 7-13-73 Detroit

10. Communication Breakdown, 6-2-73 San Fran

11. The Ocean, 5-28-73 San Diego

Disc 3 (1975-77)

1. Sick Again, 2-16-75 St. Louis

2. IMTOD, 2-12-75 NYC

3. No Quarter, 3-19-75 Vancouver

4. Trampled Underfoot, 3-19-75 Vancouver

5. Tangerine, 5-25-75 London Earls Court

6. Black Country Woman, 4-27-77 Cleveland

7. Bron Yr Aur Stomp, 4-27-77 Cleveland

8. Ten Years Gone, 5-21-77 Houston

9. It'll Be Me, 6-26-77 LA

Disc 4 (1979-80)

1. Achilles Last Stand, 7-24-79 Copenhagen

2. White Summer/Black Mountain Side, 8-11-79 Knebworth

3. Kashmir, 8-11-79 Knebworth

4. Train Kept A'Rollin, 6-18-80 Cologne

5. NFBM, 6-29-80 Zurich

6. In The Evening, 6-30-80 Frankfurt

7. All My Love, 6-30-80 Frankfurt

8. Money, 6-30-80 Frankfurt

9. Rock & Roll, 7-7-80 Berlin

10. WLL, 7-7-80 Berlin

When I re-do this, I'm planning to put something from the Long Beach 72 soundboard in place of Immigrant Song from the Manchester show. Also, I'd add Communication Breakdown from Denver '73 and change a few other things.

Edited by solar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MINE

Disc 1 1969-1972

1. The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

2. Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3. How Many More Times (March 1969 Lost Performances)

4. Dazed And Confused (March 1969 Super Show)

5. We're Gonna Groove (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

6. I Can’t Quit You (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

7. Dazed And Confused (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

8. What is and What Should Never Be (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

9. White Summer (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

10 .Moby Dick (Royal Albert Hall 1970)

11. C’mon Everybody/Something Else (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

12. Long Tall Sally (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

13. Heartbreaker (March 7,1970- Montreux)

14. Thank You (March 7,1970- Montreux)

15. Immigrant Song (June 27, 1972- Long beach)

16. Heartbreaker (June 25, 1972 - LA Forum)

17. Louie Louie (June 25, 1972 - LA Forum)

Disc 2 1973-1975

1. Celebration Day (July 27, 1973- MSG)

2. Black Dog (July 28 & 29, 1973- MSG)

3. Misty Mountain Hop (July 27 & 29, 1973 - MSG)

4.Since I've Been Loving You (July 29, 1973 - MSG)

5. No Quarter (July 27 & 28, 1973- MSG)

6. Dazed And Confused (July 27 & 29, 1973- MSG)

7. Stairway To Heaven (July 27 & 28 & 29, 1973- MSG)

8. The Ocean (July 27 & 29, 1973- MSG)

9. The Song Remains The Same (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

10. In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

11. Kashmir (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

12. Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

13. Trampled Under Foot (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

14. Dazed and Confused (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

15. Stairway To Heaven (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

16. Heartbreaker (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

17. Communication Breakdown (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

Disc 3 1977 &1980

1. The Song Remains The Same (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

2. Nobody's Fault But Mine (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

3. No Quarter (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

4. The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

5. Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

6. White Summer (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

7. Kashmir (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

8. Heartbreaker ( June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

9. Achilles Last Stand ( June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

10. Over The Top ( June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

11. Stairway To Heaven (June 23, 1977 - LA forum)

11. Whole Lotta Love/Rock And Roll ( June 23, 1977 - LA forum)

12. It’ll Be Me ( June 26, 1977 - LA forum)

13. Achilles Last Stand (July 17, 1977 - Seattle)

14. Stairway To Heaven (July 17, 1977 - Seattle)

15.Train Kept A Rollin' (June 29, 1980 - Zurich)

16. Trampled Under Foot (June 21, 1980 -Rotterdam)

Disc 4 1979

1. Black Dog (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

2. Over The Hills And Far Away (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

3. Misty Mountain Hop (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

4. No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

5. Ten Years Gone (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

6. Hot Dog (August 11, 1979 Knebworth)

7. The Rain Song (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8. Kashmir (August 4 & 11, 1979 Knebworth)

9. White Summer (August 4 & 11, 1979 Knebworth)

10. Trampled Underfoot (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

11. Sick Again (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

12. Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

13. In The Evening (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

14. Stairway To Heaven (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

15. Rock And Roll (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

16. Heartbreaker (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

17. Communication Breakdown (August 11, 1979 Knebworth)

I admire your song choice :D

(But I did say something of a realistic setlist ordering, didn't I? I seriously doubt they would play a song more than once at any show)

Post-Script: Dude, those woudn't fit. I just took a third glance at your song list, and, by my calculations, that's five discs worth of material! At LEAST!

Edited by kashmiran

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I admire your song choice :D

(But I did say something of a realistic setlist ordering, didn't I? I seriously doubt they would play a song more than once at any show)

Post-Script: Dude, those woudn't fit. I just took a third glance at your song list, and, by my calculations, that's five discs worth of material! At LEAST!

FYI, they played Dancing Days twice in Seattle in 1972. :D (http://ledzeppelin.com/show/june-19-1972)

Some of the biggest problems with creating my four-disc: not repeating certain songs, the length of D&C and NQ, picking which Heartbreaker/WLL medley to use, etc. I plan to remake my set again to get rid of some of the inferious-sounding stuff and to make an entire 1973 disc. Essentially, I want to make my own version of the "Another Trip" box set.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In answer to your Heartbreaker/WLL debate, July 28th '73 MSG is the best one I've ever heard.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
In answer to your Heartbreaker/WLL debate, July 28th '73 MSG is the best one I've ever heard.

I wholeheartedly disagree. The last few dates of first leg of the '73 tour - Dallas, Denver, San Diego, San Fran, LA - blow all three of the MSG versions away.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I wholeheartedly disagree. The last few dates of first leg of the '73 tour - Dallas, Denver, San Diego, San Fran, LA - blow all three of the MSG versions away.

Well, there you go. I've never heard any of those except Dallas, which I didn't find that fantastic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I admire your song choice :D

(But I did say something of a realistic setlist ordering, didn't I? I seriously doubt they would play a song more than once at any show)

Post-Script: Dude, those woudn't fit. I just took a third glance at your song list, and, by my calculations, that's five discs worth of material! At LEAST!

You make a good point. I guess I got carried away and forgot the set list part

This was very hard to do so many good choices for songs.

New and improved still needs work probably!

Disc 1

1.Train Kept A Rollin’ (June 29, 1980- Zurich)

2.Were Going to Grove (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

4.Celebration Day (July 1973- MSG, TSRTS)

5.Black Dog (July 1973- MSG, TSRTS)

6.Nobody's Fault But Mine (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

6.Over The Hills And Far Away (July, 1973 - MSG, TSRTS)

7.Misty Mountain Hop (July 29, 1973 - MSG)

8.Dancing Days (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

Disc 2

1.In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

2.Going to California (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

3.The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

4.Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

5.Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

6.Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977 - LA Forum)

7.No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8.Song Remains the Same (June 21, 1977 - LA Forum)

9.The Rain Song (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

10.Sick Again (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

Disc 3

1.The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

2.Trampled Underfoot (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

3.Moby Dick (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

4.Dazed and Confused (July 1973- MSG, TSRTS)

5.Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

6.White Summer (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

7.Kashmir (August 4 & 11, 1979 Knebworth)

8.In The Evening (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

Disc 4

1.Stairway to Heaven (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

2.Rock And Roll (June 27, 1972 -Long Beach HTWWW)

3.Heartbreaker (June 27, 1972 -Long Beach HTWWW)

4.Whole Lotta Love (July 1973- MSG, TSRTS)

5.The Ocean (July 1973- MSG, TSRTS)

6.Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

7.Thank You (March 7,1970- Montreux)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Disc 3:

1. Achilles Last Stand (August 11, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

As you can see, I favor the latter years more. I actually like the earlier years better, but they have been represented well enough, I think. Communication Breakdown is on disc 1, not disc 3, because it wouldn't fit on disc 3 with all those other songs on there.

;)

your joking right? the 4th is wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy better <_<

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
your joking right? the 4th is wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy better <_<

EEEK!!! You're right. I guess my head wasn't with me. At the time, the version I meant to put down was the 4th. The 11th version made me scream to the heavens: WHY!!!?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Now, though, I've aquired a better version, so I guess I'll replace the Knebworth version with this one:

Achilles Last Stand (Mix between August 4th, 1979 & June 30th, 1980 - Knebworth, England & Frankfurt, Germany respectively)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Update: New & improved!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Disc 1:

1. Rock and Roll (August 4, 1975 - Knebworth, England)

2. The Rover/Sick Again (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

3. Over the Hills and Far Away (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

4. The Song Remains the Same (January 22, 1973 - Southampton University, England)

5. The Rain Song (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

6. Kashmir (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

7. Since I've Been Loving You (July 7, 1980 - Berlin, Germany)

8. No Quarter (Mix between April 27, 1977 & March 19, 1975 - Cleveland, Ohio & Vancouver, Canada)

9. Communication Breakdown (August 11, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

10. Heartbreaker (July 7, 1980 - Berlin, Germany)

Disc 2:

1. Ten Years Gone (April 28, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

2. What is and What and What Never Be (June 27, 1972 - Long Beach Arena)

3. Trampled Under Foot (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

4. That's the Way (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

5. Going to California (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

6. White Summer/Black Mountain Side (January 9, 1970 - Royal Albert Hall)

7. The Battle of Evermore (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

8. Moby Dick (Mix between April 28, 1977 & March 20, 1975 - Cleveland, Ohio & Vancouver, Canada)

Disc 3:

1. Achilles Last Stand (Mix between August 4, 1979 & June 30, 1980 - Knebworth, England & Frankfurt, Germany)

2. Dazed and Confused (Mix between May 23, 24 & 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

3. Stairway to Heaven (Mix between May 24 & 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

4. Whole Lotta Love (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

5. The Crunge/Theremin Solo (May 23, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

6. Black Dog (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

7. Organ Solo/Thank You (June 25, 1972 - LA Forum)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Imagine: You've just won a contest to have Jimmy Page make you your own live album with your supervision. Any tracks from any date, any venue. What would your live album be. (Try to keep it to 3 or 4 discs max and in something of a realistic setlist ordering.) Here's mine:

Disc 1:

1. Rock and Roll (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

2. The Rover/Sick Again (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

3. Over the Hills and Far Away (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

4. The Song Remains the Same (January 22, 1973 - Southampton University, England)

5. The Rain Song (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

6. Kashmir (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

7. Since I've Been Loving You (July 7, 1980 - Berlin, Germany)

8. No Quarter (Mix between April 27, 1977 & March 19, 1975 - Cleveland, Ohio & Vancouver, Canada)

9. Communication Breakdown (August 11, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

Disc 2:

1. Ten Years Gone (April 28, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

2. Trampled Under Foot (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

3. That's the Way (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

4. Going to California (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

5. The Battle of Evermore (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

6. Out on the Tiles/Moby Dick (Mix between April 28, 1977 & March 20, 1975 - Cleveland, Ohio & Vancouver, Canada)

Disc 3:

1. Achilles Last Stand (August 11, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

2. Dazed and Confused (Mix between March 19 & 20, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

3. Stairway to Heaven (Mix between May 24 & 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

4. Whole Lotta Love (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

5. The Crunge/Theremin Solo (May 23, 1975 - Earl's Court)

6. Black Dog (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

As you can see, I favor the latter years more. I actually like the earlier years better, but they have been represented well enough, I think. Communication Breakdown is on disc 1, not disc 3, because it wouldn't fit on disc 3 with all those other songs on there.

;)

This would be a superb live release…but It is my opinion…and we all know about opinions…I would not mix…Reason being that as Jimmy stated…we never do the song the same twice…So to keep with tradition…release another with a different rendition…Keep in mind…making changes is…Sacrileges…Blasphemy…

Add a 4th disc…In My Time of Dying…In the Evening… Bron-Y-Aur Stomp…Tangerine…Celebration Day…Train Kept-a-Rollin…Nobodies Fault…etc…

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
This would be a superb live release…but It is my opinion…and we all know about opinions…I would not mix…Reason being that as Jimmy stated…we never do the song the same twice…So to keep with tradition…release another with a different rendition…Keep in mind…making changes is…Sacrileges…Blasphemy…

Add a 4th disc…In My Time of Dying…In the Evening… Bron-Y-Aur Stomp…Tangerine…Celebration Day…Train Kept-a-Rollin…Nobodies Fault…etc…

Well, to some extent, the "never the same way twice" rule is true. Generally, though, they're never the same way twice at different venues. But if you have multiple shows at the same venue a few times in a row, you'll usually find that they're relatively similar, at least in arrangement. That's why, as you'll see here, I tried to include songs that, if mixed, came from the same venue, same year, although there are a few exceptions (NQ, Moby Dick, ALS) where this wpould have to be done because no one venue had a perfect version.

PS - Check out my revised version toward the bottom of this page. It's even better than this one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well, to some extent, the "never the same way twice" rule is true. Generally, though, they're never the same way twice at different venues. But if you have multiple shows at the same venue a few times in a row, you'll usually find that they're relatively similar, at least in arrangement. That's why, as you'll see here, I tried to include songs that, if mixed, came from the same venue, same year, although there are a few exceptions (NQ, Moby Dick, ALS) where this wpould have to be done because no one venue had a perfect version.

PS - Check out my revised version toward the bottom of this page. It's even better than this one.

It's live...if you want perfect...spin...a studio release...live is on the edge…The edge moves...changes...

I am a purist…I still get pissed off when I here a band do a Zep Tune…I never listened to and never will listen to the tribute…Duran Duran doing Zeppelin…Give me a break…I wanted to shoot Jimmy when he dishonored Kashmir and the memory oh of John Henry by turning the tune into “Rap-Crap”…Dam I started listening to them back in 69…I remember hearing about the New Yardbirds back in 68…I loved it when they tossed the Beatles off the charts…I laughed at my friends…and still do…over 200 million units sold…

P.S. If they do an album and support it with a tour or just do a tour…I hope…Even with Jason on Drums…It will not be Led Zeppelin…Just a “Collection of Friends” doing Zeppelin…Zeppelin Died on September 24, 1980 with the death of John Henry Bonham…Bonzo…

Zeppelin is and was

John Henry Bonham

John Paul Jones (John Baldwin)

James Patrick Page

Robert Anthony Plant

and never can be again...

Edited by Outrider88

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You make a good point. I guess I got carried away and forgot the set list part

This was very hard to do so many good choices for songs.

New and improved still needs work probably!

Dream Live Album

Dream Live Album

Disc 1

1.Train Kept A Rollin’ (June 29, 1980- Zurich)

2.Were Going to Grove (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

4.Celebration Day (July 1973- MSG)

5.Black Dog (August 7, 1971- Montreux)

6.Nobody's Fault But Mine (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

6.Over The Hills And Far Away (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

7.Misty Mountain Hop (July 29, 1973 - MSG)

8.Dancing Days (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

Disc 2

1.In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

3.Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

4.Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

5.Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

6.Since I've Been Loving You (March 21, 1975- Seattle)

7.No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8.Song Remains the Same (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

9.The Rain Song (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 3

1.Sick Again (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3.Trampled Underfoot (May 25, 1975- Earl's Court)

4.Moby Dick (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

5.Dazed and Confused (July 1973- MSG)

6.Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

7.White Summer (March 7, 1970- Montreux) Into Kashmir (August 4 & 11, 1979- Knebworth)

9.In The Evening (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 4

1.Stairway to Heaven (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

2.Rock And Roll (June 27, 1972 -Long Beach)

3.Heartbreaker (March 7, 1970- Montreux)

4.Whole Lotta Love (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

5.The Ocean (July 1973- MSG)

6.Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

New and improved slightly...still pretty massive 30 so songs...im sure they could play that many though :rolleyes::D

Edited by jimmy page66

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you ask me, the better and bigger challenge is to compile all these songs into a chronological order, the way Jimmy Page had intended to do years ago. That's how I did mine. I personally don't like starting the set with a song from '80 and finishing with something from '69 for that reason.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Disc 1& 2 : A compilation of the best performance of every song performed on the 1980 tour.

Disc 3 & 4 : The o2 show.

Make these seperate releases if you want. The lack of full length official latter-days shows bothers me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...