SuperDave Posted October 8, 2008 Share Posted October 8, 2008 The Lady Who..., Noticed a couple of mistakes. You have listed during The Latter Days of the Cleveland performances in 1977 as 3/27. It's 4/27. Also, the 6/25/77 in L.A. you have the Rover. The Rover was only used as an instrumental lead in to Sick Again. And on 7/17/77 you have the place as Washington. Probably should say Seattle as not to confuse with D.C. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Lady Who's Sure Posted October 8, 2008 Share Posted October 8, 2008 The Lady Who..., Noticed a couple of mistakes. You have listed during The Latter Days of the Cleveland performances in 1977 as 3/27. It's 4/27. Also, the 6/25/77 in L.A. you have the Rover. The Rover was only used as an instrumental lead in to Sick Again. And on 7/17/77 you have the place as Washington. Probably should say Seattle as not to confuse with D.C. fixed thanks Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Olipticle Posted October 8, 2008 Share Posted October 8, 2008 1. Train Kept' A Rollin (8/31/1969) Texas Pop Festival (Houston) 2. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You (3/27/1969)Gladsax 3. Communication Breakdown (3/27/1969) Gladsax 4. Dazed And Confused (3/27/1969) Gladsax 5. Killing Floor (4/27/1969) Fillmore East San Fran 6. As Long As I Have You (4/27/1969) Fillmore East San Fran 7. I Can't Quit You Baby (12-30-1968) Spokane Disc 2 1.We're Gonna Groove (1/9/1970) RAH 2.C'mon Everybody (1/9/1970) RAH 3.Something Else (1/9/1970) RAH 4.Long Tall Sally (1/9/1970) RAH 5.Bring It On Home (1/9/1970) RAH 6.Since I've Been Loving You (8/31/1971) Orlando 7.Communication Breakdown (9-14-1971) Berkeley Disc 3 1.Going To California (9-14-1971) Berkeley 2.That's The Way (9-4-1970) LA forum 3.Bron Yr Aur (9-4-1970) LA Forum 4.What Is And What Should Never Be (9-4-1970) LA Forum 5.Out On The Tiles (9-4-1970) LA forum 6.You Shook Me (10-10-1969) London 7.How Many More Times (10-10-1969) London Disc 4 1.Moby Dick (1-9-1970) RAH 2.White Summer/Black Mountainside (1-9-1970) RAH 3.Heartbreaker (9-21-1971) Osaka 4.Whole Lotta Love (Do not know the exact date, bootleg is called "Hope You Like It Jimmy) London '71 5.Stairway To Heaven ("") London '71 6.Organ Solo (8-31-1971) Orlando 7.Thank You (8-31-1971) Orlando Sorry about the dates i dont know! PM me if you want a copy of the song to see if you can help me out 2nd Realease Middle Years: ('72-'75) Disc 1 1.Immigrant Song (6-9-1972) Charlotte 2.Rock And Roll (6-2-1972) San Fran 3.Black Dog (TSRTS) MSG 4.Over The Hills and Far Away (5-25-1975) Earls Court 5.Sick Again (3-21-1975) Seattle 6.Misty Mountain Hop (6-2-1972) San Fran 7.Since I've Been Loving You (TSRTS) MSG Disc 2 1.The Song Remains The Same (2-12-1975) MSG 2.Kashmir (2-12-1975) MSG 3.Dancing Days (6-25-1972) LA Forum 4.The Ocean (TSRTS) MSG 5.Louie, Louie / Everyday People (6-25-1972) LA Forum 6.Bring It On Home (6-25-1972) LA Forum 7.Communication Breakdown (5-25-1975) Earls Court Disc 3 1.Going To California (6-25-1972) LA Forum 2.That's The Way (6-25-1972) LA Forum 3.Tangerine (6-25-1972) LA Forum 4.Bron-Yr-Aur-Stomp (6-25-1972) LA Forum 5.Rain Song (TSRTS) MSG 6.Trampled Underfoot (5-25-1975) Earls Court 7.In My Time Of Dying (5-25-1975) Earls Court Disc 4 1.No Quarter (3-21-1975) Seattle 2.Stairway To Heaven (5-24-1975) Earls Court 3.Moby Dick (6-27-1972) LA Forum 4.Dazed and Confused (5-25-1975) Earls Court 5.Whole Lotta Love (TSRTS) MSG tough pick on the no quarter, sorry for the reappearing venues, some stuff is just too good to me left out! 3rd Release Latter Days ('77-'80) Disc 1: 1.Train Kept A Rollin (6-21-1980) Rotterdam 2.Black Dog (6-21-1980) Rotterdam 3.The Rover/Sick Again (6-25-1977) LA Forum 4.Ten Years Gone (4-27-1977) Cleveland 5.Nobody's Fault But Mine (7-23-1977) Oakland 6.Over The Hills and Far Away (7-23-1977) Oakland 7.Trampled Under Foot (7-23-1977) Oakland Disc 2: 1.The Song Remains The Same (4-27-1977) Cleveland 2.The Battle For Evermore (6-21-1980) LA Forum (JPJ got mad skills at singing) 3.Rock and Roll (6-21-1980) Rotterdam 4.Hot Dog (7-3-1980) Mannhiem 5.All My Love (7-3-1980) Mannhiem 6.Kashmir (6-29-1980) Zurich 7.In My Time Of Dying (5-21-1977) Houston Disc 3: 1.White Summer/Black Mountainside (4-27-1977) Cleveland 2.Going To California (7-23-1977) Oakland 3.Black Country Woman (7-23-1977) Oakland 4.Bron-Yr-Aur-Stomp (7-23-1977) Oakland 5.Sick Again (5-21-1977) Houston 6.In The Evening (6-29-1980) Zurich 7.Since I've Been Loving You (4-27-1977) Cleveland Disc 4: 1.Achilles Last Stand (4-27-1977) Cleveland 2.Out On The Tiles/Moby Dick (5-21-1977) Houston 3.No Quarter (4-27-1977) Cleveland 4.Stairway To Heaven (4-27-1977) Cleveland 5.Jimmy's Solo (6-25-1977) LA Forum 6.Whole Lotta Love (7-17-1977) Seattle that seems like and ultimate lp man lol agreed Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jimmy page66 Posted October 8, 2008 Share Posted October 8, 2008 If i was sir james page i believe it would be best to set up a release of such remasters in the same way the box set was released. (Early Days/Latter Days) This way, repeats of songs could be on the CD's. This is simply because Dazed and Confused from '69 and '70, and dazed and confused from '77 and '75 are practically two different songs. And for me, it applies the same with whole lotta love, because a lot of the medley's have different feels to them So: Release 1: Early Years (68-71) Disc 1 1. Train Kept' A Rollin (8/31/1969) Texas Pop Festival (Houston) 2. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You (3/27/1969)Gladsax 3. Communication Breakdown (3/27/1969) Gladsax 4. Dazed And Confused (3/27/1969) Gladsax 5. Killing Floor (4/27/1969) Fillmore East San Fran 6. As Long As I Have You (4/27/1969) Fillmore East San Fran 7. I Can't Quit You Baby (12-30-1968) Spokane Disc 2 1.We're Gonna Groove (1/9/1970) RAH 2.C'mon Everybody (1/9/1970) RAH 3.Something Else (1/9/1970) RAH 4.Long Tall Sally (1/9/1970) RAH 5.Bring It On Home (1/9/1970) RAH 6.Since I've Been Loving You (8/31/1971) Orlando 7.Communication Breakdown (9-14-1971) Berkeley Disc 3 1.Going To California (9-14-1971) Berkeley 2.That's The Way (9-4-1970) LA forum 3.Bron Yr Aur (9-4-1970) LA Forum 4.What Is And What Should Never Be (9-4-1970) LA Forum 5.Out On The Tiles (9-4-1970) LA forum 6.You Shook Me (10-10-1969) London 7.How Many More Times (10-10-1969) London Disc 4 1.Moby Dick (1-9-1970) RAH 2.White Summer/Black Mountainside (1-9-1970) RAH 3.Heartbreaker (9-21-1971) Osaka 4.Whole Lotta Love (Do not know the exact date, bootleg is called "Hope You Like It Jimmy) London '71 5.Stairway To Heaven ("") London '71 6.Organ Solo (8-31-1971) Orlando 7.Thank You (8-31-1971) Orlando Sorry about the dates i dont know! PM me if you want a copy of the song to see if you can help me out 2nd Realease Middle Years: ('72-'75) Disc 1 1.Immigrant Song (6-9-1972) Charlotte 2.Rock And Roll (6-2-1972) San Fran 3.Black Dog (TSRTS) MSG 4.Over The Hills and Far Away (5-25-1975) Earls Court 5.Sick Again (3-21-1975) Seattle 6.Misty Mountain Hop (6-2-1972) San Fran 7.Since I've Been Loving You (TSRTS) MSG Disc 2 1.The Song Remains The Same (2-12-1975) MSG 2.Kashmir (2-12-1975) MSG 3.Dancing Days (6-25-1972) LA Forum 4.The Ocean (TSRTS) MSG 5.Louie, Louie / Everyday People (6-25-1972) LA Forum 6.Bring It On Home (6-25-1972) LA Forum 7.Communication Breakdown (5-25-1975) Earls Court Disc 3 1.Going To California (6-25-1972) LA Forum 2.That's The Way (6-25-1972) LA Forum 3.Tangerine (6-25-1972) LA Forum 4.Bron-Yr-Aur-Stomp (6-25-1972) LA Forum 5.Rain Song (TSRTS) MSG 6.Trampled Underfoot (5-25-1975) Earls Court 7.In My Time Of Dying (5-25-1975) Earls Court Disc 4 1.No Quarter (3-21-1975) Seattle 2.Stairway To Heaven (5-24-1975) Earls Court 3.Moby Dick (6-27-1972) LA Forum 4.Dazed and Confused (5-25-1975) Earls Court 5.Whole Lotta Love (TSRTS) MSG tough pick on the no quarter, sorry for the reappearing venues, some stuff is just too good to me left out! 3rd Release Latter Days ('77-'80) Disc 1: 1.Train Kept A Rollin (6-21-1980) Rotterdam 2.Black Dog (6-21-1980) Rotterdam 3.The Rover/Sick Again (6-25-1977) LA Forum 4.Ten Years Gone (4-27-1977) Cleveland 5.Nobody's Fault But Mine (7-23-1977) Oakland 6.Over The Hills and Far Away (7-23-1977) Oakland 7.Trampled Under Foot (7-23-1977) Oakland Disc 2: 1.The Song Remains The Same (4-27-1977) Cleveland 2.The Battle For Evermore (6-21-1980) LA Forum (JPJ got mad skills at singing) 3.Rock and Roll (6-21-1980) Rotterdam 4.Hot Dog (7-3-1980) Mannhiem 5.All My Love (7-3-1980) Mannhiem 6.Kashmir (6-29-1980) Zurich 7.In My Time Of Dying (5-21-1977) Houston Disc 3: 1.White Summer/Black Mountainside (4-27-1977) Cleveland 2.Going To California (7-23-1977) Oakland 3.Black Country Woman (7-23-1977) Oakland 4.Bron-Yr-Aur-Stomp (7-23-1977) Oakland 5.Sick Again (5-21-1977) Houston 6.In The Evening (6-29-1980) Zurich 7.Since I've Been Loving You (4-27-1977) Cleveland Disc 4: 1.Achilles Last Stand (4-27-1977) Cleveland 2.Out On The Tiles/Moby Dick (5-21-1977) Houston 3.No Quarter (4-27-1977) Cleveland 4.Stairway To Heaven (4-27-1977) Cleveland 5.Jimmy's Solo (6-25-1977) LA Forum 6.Whole Lotta Love (7-17-1977) Seattle Feel free to point out any mistakes i may have made more or less, this is simply my favorite versions of each of these songs this is how i would do it at least, feel free to chat about this too! 1. Plant couldn't sing for shit on 2-12-75 on TSRTS 2. Really that may be the worst and boring D&C I have heard 3. They didn't play TUF at Oakland.. 4. Zurich Kashmir is the worst Kashmir to date. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Lady Who's Sure Posted October 9, 2008 Share Posted October 9, 2008 1. Plant couldn't sing for shit on 2-12-75 on TSRTS 2. Really that may be the worst and boring D&C I have heard 3. They didn't play TUF at Oakland.. 4. Zurich Kashmir is the worst Kashmir to date. 1.i like the guitar on TSRTS 2.wasnt sure on what dazed and confused to use from those tours, i really haven't listened to enough D&C, feel free to make suggestions 3. according to my oakland recording, TUF was played 4. i love this kashmir, very clean feel free to make improvements Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SuperDave Posted October 9, 2008 Share Posted October 9, 2008 1.i like the guitar on TSRTS 2.wasnt sure on what dazed and confused to use from those tours, i really haven't listened to enough D&C, feel free to make suggestions 3. according to my oakland recording, TUF was played 4. i love this kashmir, very clean feel free to make improvements It's all a matter of opinion and individual taste. That's what makes this forum so good. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kdh Posted October 9, 2008 Share Posted October 9, 2008 The Dream Live Album would be the one Jimmy Page releases. Yes, I know about the Led Zeppelin DVD, How the West Was One, BBC Recordings. There are other tours with great performances of songs that have to be ProTooled into public buying consumption. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kashmiran Posted December 23, 2008 Author Share Posted December 23, 2008 After 1000 drafts, here's my FOUR-DISC revision: Disc 1: 1. Rock and Roll (June 27th, 1972 - Long Beach, California) 2. The Rover [Excerpt] (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 3. Sick Again (August 4th, 1979 - Knebworth, U.K.) 4. Over the Hills and Far Away (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 5. The Song Remains the Same (January 22nd, 1973 - Southampton, U.K.) 6. The Rain Song (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 7. Kashmir (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 8. How Many More Times (January 9th, 1970 - Royal Albert Hall, U.K.) Disc 2: 1. Misty Mountain Hop (January 22nd, 1973 - Southampton, U.K.) 2. Since I've Been Loving You (April 28th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 3. Ten Years Gone (June 21st, 1977 - LA Forum) 4. Trampled Underfoot (May 25th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 5. Nobody's Fault But Mine (August 4th, 1979 - Knebworth, U.K.) 6. In My Time of Dying (May 24th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 7. Dancing Days (January 22nd, 1973 - Southampton, U.K.) Disc 3: 1. No Quarter (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 2. White Summer / Black Mountain Side (January 9th, 1970 - Royal Albert Hall, U.K.) 3. Tangerine (May 24th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 4. That's the Way (May 25th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 5. The Battle of Evermore (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 6. Going to California (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 7. Out on the Tiles / Over the Top / Moby Dick (June 23rd, 1977 - Los Angeles, California) Disc 4: 1. Dazed and Confused (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 2. Achilles Last Stand (June 30th, 1980 - Frankfurt, Germany) 3. Stairway to Heaven (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 4. Whole Lotta Love (August 11th, 1979 - Knebworth, U.K.) 5. Heartbreaker (June 29th, 1980 - Zurich, Switzerland) 6. Communication Breakdown (May 25th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 7. Organ Solo (July 25th, 1972 - Los Angeles, California) 8. Thank You (July 25th, 1972 - Los Angeles, California) ---------------------- Tried not to include anything released legitimately on CD. Stuff from the DVD I condsider fair game though, because that stuff hasn't been released on CD legit yet. I tried to only use good shows that seem to have similar sound (IMO). Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MisterMcLov1n Posted December 23, 2008 Share Posted December 23, 2008 All I want is for the Led Zeppelin Live DVD audio turned into a CD, honestly. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EzyEric Posted December 23, 2008 Share Posted December 23, 2008 All I want is for the Led Zeppelin Live DVD audio turned into a CD, honestly. its out there im sure. I ripped it myself. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
markreed Posted December 28, 2008 Share Posted December 28, 2008 As far as I am concerned, it would be fitting for LZ to honour each year of their live existence with an official live album : 1975,77,79/80, and 2007 are under-represented in the live album arena. Sure, we have DVD footage for some of those, but that's not the same thing. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LedZep4Ever Posted December 29, 2008 Share Posted December 29, 2008 As far as I am concerned, it would be fitting for LZ to honour each year of their live existence with an official live album : 1975,77,79/80, and 2007 are under-represented in the live album arena. Sure, we have DVD footage for some of those, but that's not the same thing. I totally agree! I pray some day, they will do something like that!!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kashmiran Posted January 7, 2009 Author Share Posted January 7, 2009 its out there im sure. I ripped it myself. Me too. This version of SIBLY came in handy for correcting the missing beat on TSRTS remastered version. Also helped with making BD complete. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kashmiran Posted January 7, 2009 Author Share Posted January 7, 2009 After 1000 drafts, here's my FOUR-DISC revision: Disc 1: 1. Rock and Roll (June 27th, 1972 - Long Beach, California) 2. The Rover [Excerpt] (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 3. Sick Again (August 4th, 1979 - Knebworth, U.K.) 4. Over the Hills and Far Away (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 5. The Song Remains the Same (January 22nd, 1973 - Southampton, U.K.) 6. The Rain Song (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 7. Kashmir (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 8. How Many More Times (January 9th, 1970 - Royal Albert Hall, U.K.) Disc 2: 1. Misty Mountain Hop (January 22nd, 1973 - Southampton, U.K.) 2. Since I've Been Loving You (April 28th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 3. Ten Years Gone (June 21st, 1977 - LA Forum) 4. Trampled Underfoot (May 25th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 5. Nobody's Fault But Mine (August 4th, 1979 - Knebworth, U.K.) 6. In My Time of Dying (May 24th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 7. Dancing Days (January 22nd, 1973 - Southampton, U.K.) Disc 3: 1. No Quarter (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 2. White Summer / Black Mountain Side (January 9th, 1970 - Royal Albert Hall, U.K.) 3. Tangerine (May 24th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 4. That's the Way (May 25th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 5. The Battle of Evermore (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 6. Going to California (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 7. Out on the Tiles / Over the Top / Moby Dick (June 23rd, 1977 - Los Angeles, California) Disc 4: 1. Dazed and Confused (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 2. Achilles Last Stand (June 30th, 1980 - Frankfurt, Germany) 3. Stairway to Heaven (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 4. Whole Lotta Love (August 11th, 1979 - Knebworth, U.K.) 5. Heartbreaker (June 29th, 1980 - Zurich, Switzerland) 6. Communication Breakdown (May 25th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 7. Organ Solo (July 25th, 1972 - Los Angeles, California) 8. Thank You (July 25th, 1972 - Los Angeles, California) ---------------------- Tried not to include anything released legitimately on CD. Stuff from the DVD I condsider fair game though, because that stuff hasn't been released on CD legit yet. I tried to only use good shows that seem to have similar sound (IMO). 1001: (Mostly corrections so as to fit properly) Disc 1: 1. Rock and Roll (February 27th, 1972 - Sydney, Australia) 2. The Rover [Excerpt] (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 3. Sick Again (August 4th, 1979 - Knebworth, U.K.) 4. Heartbreaker (June 29th, 1980 - Zurich, Switzerland) 5. Over the Hills and Far Away (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 6. The Song Remains the Same (January 22nd, 1973 - Southampton, U.K.) 7. The Rain Song (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 8. Kashmir (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) Disc 2: 1. Misty Mountain Hop (January 22nd, 1973 - Southampton, U.K.) 2. Since I've Been Loving You (April 28th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 3. Trampled Underfoot (May 25th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 4. Nobody's Fault But Mine (August 4th, 1979 - Knebworth, U.K.) 5. In My Time of Dying (May 24th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 6. Dancing Days (January 22nd, 1973 - Southampton, U.K.) 7. No Quarter (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) Disc 3: 1. White Summer / Black Mountain Side (January 9th, 1970 - Royal Albert Hall, U.K.) 2. Tangerine (May 24th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 3. That's the Way (May 25th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 4. Going to California (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 5. The Battle of Evermore (April 27th, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio) 6. Ten Years Gone (June 21st, 1977 - LA Forum) 7. Out on the Tiles / Over the Top / Moby Dick (June 23rd, 1977 - Los Angeles, California) Disc 4: 1. Dazed and Confused (January 9th, 1970 - Royal Albert Hall, U.K.) 2. Achilles Last Stand (June 30th, 1980 - Frankfurt, Germany) 3. Stairway to Heaven (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 4. Black Dog (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada) 5. Whole Lotta Love (August 11th, 1979 - Knebworth, U.K.) 6. Communication Breakdown (May 25th, 1975 - Earl's Court, U.K.) 7. Organ Solo (July 25th, 1972 - Los Angeles, California) 8. Thank You (July 25th, 1972 - Los Angeles, California) Only a couple of actual changes. Mostly just order changes. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LEDMAN!! Posted January 8, 2009 Share Posted January 8, 2009 I'd just have every performance of Dazed and Confused from 1968 - 1970. AMEN!!!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.