ZeppFanForever Posted July 22, 2008 Share Posted July 22, 2008 This question is for all of my fellow die hard hard core ZEPPELIN fanatics. In your opinion, where was the best live version of "Over The Hills And Far Away" performed at? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jimmy page66 Posted July 22, 2008 Share Posted July 22, 2008 This question is for all of my fellow die hard hard core ZEPPELIN fanatics. In your opinion, where was the best live version of "Over The Hills And Far Away" performed at? Vienna 16th 1973 Knebworth 4th MSG 1975 12th Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ZeppFanForever Posted July 22, 2008 Author Share Posted July 22, 2008 Vienna 16th 1973 Knebworth 4th MSG 1975 12th Great choices! I do feel that Knebworth 11th might have made the cut if the audio problems weren't so persistent. ROCK ON! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jimmy page66 Posted July 22, 2008 Share Posted July 22, 2008 may i add Vancouver 19th 75...your right about the 11th to. i hate the 77 versions though Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LedZep1969 Posted July 22, 2008 Share Posted July 22, 2008 HTWWW hands down Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jimmy page66 Posted July 22, 2008 Share Posted July 22, 2008 HTWWW hands downthat solos weak sauce in that Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LedZep1969 Posted July 22, 2008 Share Posted July 22, 2008 that solos weak sauce in that or from MSG '73 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ZeppFanForever Posted July 22, 2008 Author Share Posted July 22, 2008 or from MSG '73 Great choices everyone! What about Earl's Court 24 and 25 May 1975? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
chef free Posted July 22, 2008 Share Posted July 22, 2008 6/23/77 all the way! When was the last you listened to this one? Page destroys the audience then whups on his own band, awsome (3/16/73 IS pretty hot too.) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ZeppFanForever Posted July 22, 2008 Author Share Posted July 22, 2008 6/21/77 all the way! When was the last you listened to this one? Bonham is back with a vengence! (3/16/73 IS pretty hot too.) I actually listened to "For Badgeholders Only" from 21 June 1977 yesterday and it sounded great. I especially love the way they performed "Kashmir." I attended The Forum show from 23 June 1977 and from what I can remember (Give or take a brain cell), it was the greatest concert that I ever saw in my whole life. I also saw the Oakland Coliseum concert on 23 July 1977, however, sadly, it does not live up to any of The Forum shows. I still love the Oakland show though. ROCK ON! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EzyEric Posted July 22, 2008 Share Posted July 22, 2008 2-12-75 MSG (Flying Circus) Until further notice, I'm only 15-25% through all the recommended bootlegs Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ZeppFanForever Posted July 22, 2008 Author Share Posted July 22, 2008 2-12-75 MSG (Flying Circus) Until further notice, I'm only 15-25% through all the recommended bootlegs Sounds to me like you have a lot of shows like myself. So many shows, so little time. ROCK ON! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cowbell666 Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 i'm not a huge fan of the song from 2/12/75. Robert's voice was really off during that show. i only like the 1972 versions, where Robert can really hit the high notes. after '72 i just hate the vocal part... my absolute favorite is from 6/25/72 LA. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EzyEric Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 i'm not a huge fan of the song from 2/12/75. Robert's voice was really off during that show. i only like the 1972 versions, where Robert can really hit the high notes. after '72 i just hate the vocal part... my absolute favorite is from 6/25/72 LA. I base it mostly off Pages solo. This was one of the first songs I noticed Plants vocals lacking on my own (this was the only bootleg i had, among the official live stuff, until very recently that is) because he doesnt go high on "many times....!!" But, I hope i find a better one, I think I already did for my very fav. song, NQ. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ZeppFanForever Posted July 23, 2008 Author Share Posted July 23, 2008 I base it mostly off Pages solo. This was one of the first songs I noticed Plants vocals lacking on my own (this was the only bootleg i had, among the official live stuff, until very recently that is) because he doesnt go high on "many times....!!" But, I hope i find a better one, I think I already did for my very fav. song, NQ. NOW THAT IS WHAT I CALL SERIOUS DIE HARD ZEPPELIN FANATICS! ROCK ON! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SeanBond Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 Aren't there just two versions? Or three, one on the DVD too? What are all these other dates I see? I've never heard of those cd's. The best version of those that are out is on the West Was One cd. The other two don't have the mojo. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jimmy page66 Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 Aren't there just two versions? Or three, one on the DVD too? What are all these other dates I see? I've never heard of those cd's. The best version of those that are out is on the West Was One cd. The other two don't have the mojo.Your fucking kidding me I hope! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SeanBond Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 Your fucking kidding me I hope! No, I really do think the West Was One cd is the best. Robert Plant's voice sounds rough on the other 2. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jimmy page66 Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 No, I really do think the West Was One cd is the best. Robert Plant's voice sounds rough on the other 2. there are way more then 3 version dude! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SeanBond Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 Oh. Are they listed here? I was told this is the definitive Led Zeppelin website, so please point me to all these versions everyone is talking about. I haven't found that section yet. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jimmy page66 Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 Oh. Are they listed here? I was told this is the definitive Led Zeppelin website, so please point me to all these versions everyone is talking about. I haven't found that section yet. [DIR] 1972.05.28 Brussels/ 12-Jul-2008 14:43 - [DIR] 1972.06.07 Montreal/ 07-Jun-2008 20:11 - [DIR] 1972.06.09 Charlotte/ 07-Jun-2008 22:00 - [DIR] 1972.06.11 Baltimore/ 08-Jun-2008 00:38 - [DIR] 1972.06.13 Philadel..> 08-Jun-2008 01:55 - [DIR] 1972.06.14 Uniondale/ 08-Jun-2008 04:03 - [DIR] 1972.06.15 Uniondale/ 08-Jun-2008 09:49 - [DIR] 1972.06.19 Seattle/ 08-Jun-2008 11:54 - [DIR] 1972.06.22 San Bern..> 08-Jun-2008 14:53 - [DIR] 1972.06.26 Los Ange..> 08-Jun-2008 15:02 - [DIR] 1972.06.27 Long Beach/ 29-Jun-2008 22:35 - [DIR] 1972.06.28 Tucson/ 08-Jun-2008 16:56 - [DIR] 1972.10.02 Tokyo/ 09-Jun-2008 02:16 - [DIR] 1972.10.03 Tokyo/ 09-Jun-2008 04:21 - [DIR] 1972.10.04 Osaka/ 09-Jun-2008 06:11 - [DIR] 1972.10.05 Nagoya/ 23-Jun-2008 19:19 - [DIR] 1972.10.09 Osaka/ 09-Jun-2008 09:12 - [DIR] 1972.10.10 Kyoto/ 09-Jun-2008 11:57 - [DIR] 1972.11.30 Newcastle/ 09-Jun-2008 14:08 - [DIR] 1972.12.01 Newcastle/ 09-Jun-2008 14:53 - [DIR] 1972.12.04 Glasgow/ 09-Jun-2008 17:47 - [DIR] 1972.12.08 Manchester/ 09-Jun-2008 21:07 - [DIR] 1972.12.12 Cardiff/ 09-Jun-2008 21:38 - [DIR] 1972.12.16 Birmingham/ 09-Jun-2008 23:41 - [DIR] 1972.12.20 Brighton/ 10-Jun-2008 00:31 - [DIR] 1972.12.22 London/ 28-Jun-2008 20:46 - [DIR] 1972.12.23 London/ 10-Jun-2008 11:08 - [DIR] 1973.01.02 Sheffield/ 10-Jun-2008 12:58 - [DIR] 1973.01.07 Oxford/ 10-Jun-2008 14:12 - [DIR] 1973.01.14 Liverpool/ 10-Jun-2008 15:24 - [DIR] 1973.01.15 Stoke/ 10-Jun-2008 16:46 - [DIR] 1973.01.18 Bradford/ 11-Jun-2008 07:55 - [DIR] 1973.01.22 Southamp..> 11-Jun-2008 11:12 - [DIR] 1973.01.25 Aberdeen/ 11-Jun-2008 17:35 - [DIR] 1973.01.27 Dundee/ 16-Jun-2008 16:57 - [DIR] 1973.01.28 Edinburgh/ 24-Jun-2008 11:56 - [DIR] 1973.01.30 Preston/ 11-Jun-2008 20:05 - [DIR] 1973.03.06 Stockholm/ 11-Jun-2008 22:20 - [DIR] 1973.03.16 Vienna/ 12-Jun-2008 00:09 - [DIR] 1973.03.17 Munich/ 12-Jun-2008 03:07 - [DIR] 1973.03.19 Berlin/ 12-Jun-2008 05:06 - [DIR] 1973.03.21 Hamburg/ 12-Jun-2008 06:57 - [DIR] 1973.03.22 Essen/ 12-Jun-2008 10:17 - [DIR] 1973.03.24 Offenburg/ 12-Jun-2008 13:17 - [DIR] 1973.03.26 Lyon/ 28-Jun-2008 15:27 - [DIR] 1973.03.27 Nancy/ 12-Jun-2008 14:29 - [DIR] 1973.04.01 Paris/ 12-Jun-2008 16:05 - [DIR] 1973.04.02 Paris/ 12-Jun-2008 18:00 - [DIR] 1973.05.05 Tampa/ 13-Jun-2008 19:48 - [DIR] 1973.05.13 Mobile/ 13-Jun-2008 23:17 - [DIR] 1973.05.14 New Orle..> 14-Jun-2008 01:07 - [DIR] 1973.05.16 Houston/ 14-Jun-2008 03:11 - [DIR] 1973.05.18 Dallas/ 14-Jun-2008 05:23 - [DIR] 1973.05.19 Fort Worth/ 14-Jun-2008 09:45 - [DIR] 1973.05.25 Denver/ 14-Jun-2008 10:38 - [DIR] 1973.05.26 Salt Lak..> 14-Jun-2008 14:02 - [DIR] 1973.05.28 San Diego/ 14-Jun-2008 12:19 - [DIR] 1973.05.31 Los Ange..> 14-Jun-2008 15:22 - [DIR] 1973.06.02 San Fran..> 14-Jun-2008 18:50 - [DIR] 1973.06.03 Los Ange..> 14-Jun-2008 22:20 - [DIR] 1973.07.06 Chicago/ 15-Jun-2008 04:08 - [DIR] 1973.07.07 Chicago/ 15-Jun-2008 06:35 - [DIR] 1973.07.09 St Paul/ 15-Jun-2008 12:27 - [DIR] 1973.07.10 Milwaukee/ 15-Jun-2008 08:09 - [DIR] 1973.07.12 Detroit/ 15-Jun-2008 14:53 - [DIR] 1973.07.13 Detroit/ 15-Jun-2008 15:40 - [DIR] 1973.07.15 Buffalo/ 07-Jul-2008 20:52 - [DIR] 1973.07.17 Seattle/ 15-Jun-2008 18:19 - [DIR] 1973.07.18 Vancouver/ 15-Jun-2008 20:44 - [DIR] 1973.07.20 Boston/ 16-Jun-2008 02:20 - [DIR] 1973.07.21 Providence/ 16-Jun-2008 04:27 - [DIR] 1973.07.23 Baltimore/ 15-Jun-2008 10:23 - [DIR] 1973.07.27 New York/ 16-Jun-2008 06:04 - [DIR] 1973.07.29 New York/ 16-Jun-2008 09:50 - [DIR] 1975.01.12 Brussels/ 26-Jun-2008 21:03 - [DIR] 1975.01.20 Chicago/ 16-Jun-2008 18:43 - [DIR] 1975.01.24 Cleveland/ 25-Jun-2008 02:45 - [DIR] 1975.01.25 Indianap..> 16-Jun-2008 20:26 - [DIR] 1975.01.29 Greensboro/ 16-Jun-2008 22:03 - [DIR] 1975.01.31 Detroit/ 16-Jun-2008 23:48 - [DIR] 1975.02.03 New York/ 17-Jun-2008 03:24 - [DIR] 1975.02.04 Uniondale/ 17-Jun-2008 04:37 - [DIR] 1975.02.06 Montreal/ 08-Jul-2008 13:08 - [DIR] 1975.02.07 New York/ 20-Jun-2008 15:35 - [DIR] 1975.02.08 Philadel..> 17-Jun-2008 11:05 - [DIR] 1975.02.10 Landover/ 17-Jun-2008 14:30 - [DIR] 1975.02.12 New York/ 20-Jun-2008 15:33 - [DIR] 1975.02.13 Uniondale/ 26-Jun-2008 20:09 - [DIR] 1975.02.14 Uniondale/ 18-Jun-2008 01:24 - [DIR] 1975.02.16 St Louis/ 18-Jun-2008 08:31 - [DIR] 1975.02.28 Baton Ro..> 20-Jun-2008 15:31 - [DIR] 1975.03.04 Dallas/ 18-Jun-2008 21:56 - [DIR] 1975.03.05 Dallas/ 20-Jun-2008 15:30 - [DIR] 1975.03.10 San Diego/ 20-Jun-2008 15:30 - [DIR] 1975.03.11 Long Beach/ 20-Jun-2008 15:30 - [DIR] 1975.03.12 Long Beach/ 20-Jun-2008 02:04 - [DIR] 1975.03.14 San Diego/ 20-Jun-2008 15:29 - [DIR] 1975.03.17 Seattle/ 20-Jun-2008 09:05 - [DIR] 1975.03.19 Vancouver/ 23-Jun-2008 21:56 - [DIR] 1975.03.20 Vancouver/ 24-Jun-2008 10:32 - [DIR] 1975.03.21 Seattle/ 09-Jul-2008 00:00 - [DIR] 1975.03.24 Los Ange..> 24-Jun-2008 01:50 - [DIR] 1975.03.25 Los Ange..> 24-Jun-2008 04:39 - [DIR] 1975.03.27 Los Ange..> 24-Jun-2008 07:34 - [DIR] 1975.05.17 London/ 24-Jun-2008 14:48 - [DIR] 1975.05.18 London/ 29-Jun-2008 19:49 - [DIR] 1975.05.23 London/ 26-Jun-2008 20:09 - [DIR] 1975.05.24 London/ 24-Jun-2008 21:13 - [DIR] 1975.05.25 London/ 25-Jun-2008 00:29 - [DIR] 1977.04.03 Oklahoma..> 25-Jun-2008 12:02 - [DIR] 1977.04.06 Chicago/ 25-Jun-2008 15:10 - [DIR] 1977.04.07 Chicago/ 08-Jul-2008 11:11 - [DIR] 1977.04.09 Chicago/ 25-Jun-2008 20:57 - [DIR] 1977.04.10 Chicago/ 25-Jun-2008 22:07 - [DIR] 1977.04.19 Cincinnati/ 15-Jun-2008 23:16 - [DIR] 1977.04.20 Cincinnati/ 26-Jun-2008 00:01 - [DIR] 1977.04.23 Atlanta/ 26-Jun-2008 02:12 - [DIR] 1977.04.25 Louisville/ 25-Jun-2008 10:38 - [DIR] 1977.04.27 Cleveland/ 25-Jun-2008 10:38 - [DIR] 1977.04.28 Cleveland/ 26-Jun-2008 04:57 - [DIR] 1977.04.30 Pontiac/ 26-Jun-2008 08:06 - [DIR] 1977.05.18 Birmingham/ 26-Jun-2008 10:41 - [DIR] 1977.05.21 Houston/ 26-Jun-2008 10:22 - [DIR] 1977.05.22 Ft. Worth/ 26-Jun-2008 08:13 - [DIR] 1977.05.25 Landover/ 25-Jun-2008 20:52 - [DIR] 1977.05.26 Landover/ 26-Jun-2008 19:55 - [DIR] 1977.05.28 Landover/ 27-Jun-2008 01:47 - [DIR] 1977.05.30 Landover/ 16-Jun-2008 12:21 - [DIR] 1977.06.03 Tampa/ 13-Jun-2008 16:06 - [DIR] 1977.06.07 New York/ 15-Jun-2008 20:43 - [DIR] 1977.06.08 New York/ 15-Jun-2008 20:42 - [DIR] 1977.06.10 New York/ 12-Jun-2008 17:36 - [DIR] 1977.06.11 New York/ 25-Jun-2008 09:51 - [DIR] 1977.06.13 New York/ 10-Jun-2008 14:31 - [DIR] 1977.06.14 New York/ 27-Jun-2008 00:15 - [DIR] 1977.06.19 San Diego/ 10-Jul-2008 18:08 - [DIR] 1977.06.21 Los Ange..> 09-Jun-2008 15:25 - [DIR] 1977.06.22 Los Ange..> 26-Jun-2008 10:38 - [DIR] 1977.06.23 Los Ange..> 06-Jun-2008 23:40 - [DIR] 1977.06.25 Los Ange..> 09-Jun-2008 13:37 - [DIR] 1977.06.26 Los Ange..> 10-Jun-2008 10:03 - [DIR] 1977.06.27 Los Ange..> 26-Jun-2008 16:25 - [DIR] 1977.07.17 Seattle/ 06-Jun-2008 15:45 - [DIR] 1977.07.20 Tempe/ 06-Jun-2008 16:00 - [DIR] 1977.07.23 Oakland/ 06-Jun-2008 15:59 - [DIR] 1977.07.24 Oakland/ 06-Jun-2008 23: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cowbell666 Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 HAHAHA, dude! that's probably the funniest post I've ever seen!!! but fyi not all those dates have OTHAFA. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jimmy page66 Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 HAHAHA, dude! that's probably the funniest post I've ever seen!!! but fyi not all those dates have OTHAFA. almost all, give or take dates in 77 replaced by IMTOD Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cowbell666 Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 almost all, give or take dates in 77 replaced by IMTOD i think the first time they played it live was 6/19/72, and 6/25 was the 2nd time they ever played it live. i was at the 5/9/72 show in Charlotte and they didn't play it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LeZoso Posted July 23, 2008 Share Posted July 23, 2008 For me: L.A. 6/27/1977. Unbelievable Guitar-Solo from Jimmy. It's the best what I ever heard. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.