Dream live album (imagine...)

[jimmy page66]

If you ask me, the better and bigger challenge is to compile all these songs into a chronological order, the way Jimmy Page had intended to do years ago. That's how I did mine. I personally don't like starting the set with a song from '80 and finishing with something from '69 for that reason.

well the rules said a set list i did a chronological order one up a few but it had to many songs and it wasn't a good set list

[jimmy page66]

1.Rock and Roll (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.Train Kept A Rollin’ (June 29, 1980- Zurich)

4.Celebration Day (July 27 1973- MSG)

5.Black Dog (August 7, 1971- Montreux)

6.Nobody's Fault But Mine (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

6.Over The Hills And Far Away (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)*

7.Misty Mountain Hop (July 29, 1973 - MSG)*

8.Dancing Days (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

Disc 2

1.In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

3.Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

4.Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

5.Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)**

6.Since I've Been Loving You (March 21, 1975- Seattle)

7.No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8.Song Remains the Same (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

9.The Rain Song (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 3

1.Sick Again (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3.Trampled Underfoot (May 25, 1975- Earl's Court)

4.Moby Dick (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

5.Dazed and Confused (July 1973- MSG)

6.Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

7.White Summer (March 7, 1970- Montreux)** Into Kashmir (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

8.In The Evening (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 4

1.Stairway to Heaven (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.Whole Lotta Love (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

3.Heartbreaker (March 7, 1970- Montreux)*

4.The Ocean (July 29, 1973- MSG)

5.Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

*Any other suggestions...

**other choices....

[solar]

1.Rock and Roll (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.Train Kept A Rollin’ (June 29, 1980- Zurich)

4.Celebration Day (July 27 1973- MSG)

5.Black Dog (August 7, 1971- Montreux)

6.Nobody's Fault But Mine (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

6.Over The Hills And Far Away (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)*

7.Misty Mountain Hop (July 29, 1973 - MSG)*

8.Dancing Days (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

Disc 2

1.In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

3.Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

4.Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

5.Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)**

6.Since I've Been Loving You (March 21, 1975- Seattle)

7.No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8.Song Remains the Same (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

9.The Rain Song (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 3

1.Sick Again (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3.Trampled Underfoot (May 25, 1975- Earl's Court)

4.Moby Dick (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

5.Dazed and Confused (July 1973- MSG)

6.Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

7.White Summer (March 7, 1970- Montreux)** Into Kashmir (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

8.In The Evening (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 4

1.Stairway to Heaven (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.Whole Lotta Love (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

3.Heartbreaker (March 7, 1970- Montreux)*

4.The Ocean (July 29, 1973- MSG)

5.Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

*Any other suggestions...

**other choices....

Suggestions:

- Don't use a 73 Misty Mountain Hop, as it bleeds into SIBLY. I'd use Dancing Days from Southampton '73 or Long Beach '72 instead.

- Not a fan of blending a '70 White Summer with a '79 Kashmir - especially considering the quality of the sources available would not match up well. It'd be better to use the same show for the WS/Kashmir combo, perhaps the Knebworth version you mentioned.

- By using the best quality Dancing Days, that would free you up to use the Vienna OTHFA, which is a scorching version.

- I'm a huge fan of the WLL/Heartbreaker medley from the '73 tour and would probably replace that with the two songs on Disc 4. The Denver, San Diego, San Francisco and LA versions are all phenomenal.

- Nothing from the 4/27/77 Cleveland Detroyer show?

- Another great substitute would be WIAWSNB from the '72 Long Beach board tape.

- Also, The Lemon Song from 4/27 was still being played under its original title of Killing Floor. Just a point of semantics.

[jimmy page66]

1.Rock and Roll (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)*

2.Black Dog (August 7, 1971- Montreux)**

4.Celebration Day (July 1973- MSG)

5.Train Kept A Rollin’ (June 29, 1980- Zurich)

6.Nobody's Fault But Mine (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

6.Over The Hills And Far Away (March 16, 1973- Vienna)**

7.Misty Mountain Hop (October 9, 1972- Osaka)

8.Dancing Days (June 27, 1972- Long Beach)

Disc 2

1.In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

3.Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

4.Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

5.Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

6.Since I've Been Loving You (March 21, 1975- Seattle)

7.No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8.Song Remains the Same (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

9.The Rain Song (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 3

1.Sick Again (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3.Trampled Underfoot (May 25, 1975- Earl's Court)

4.Moby Dick (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

5.Dazed and Confused (July 1973- MSG)**

6.Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

7.White Summer (August 4, 1979- Knebworth) Into Kashmir (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

8.In The Evening (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 4

1.Stairway to Heaven (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.Whole Lotta Love (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

3.Heartbreaker (March 7, 1970- Montreux)**

4.The Ocean (July 29, 1973- MSG)

5.Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

*Any other suggestions...

**other choices

1.black dog (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

2.Over The Hills And Far Away (June 25, 1972)

3.Dazed and Confused (May 24, 1975- Earls court)

4.Heartbreaker (June 27, 1972- Long beach..

[jimmy page66]

Suggestions:

- Don't use a 73 Misty Mountain Hop, as it bleeds into SIBLY. I'd use Dancing Days from Southampton '73 or Long Beach '72 instead.

- Not a fan of blending a '70 White Summer with a '79 Kashmir - especially considering the quality of the sources available would not match up well. It'd be better to use the same show for the WS/Kashmir combo, perhaps the Knebworth version you mentioned.

- By using the best quality Dancing Days, that would free you up to use the Vienna OTHFA, which is a scorching version.

- I'm a huge fan of the WLL/Heartbreaker medley from the '73 tour and would probably replace that with the two songs on Disc 4. The Denver, San Diego, San Francisco and LA versions are all phenomenal.

- Nothing from the 4/27/77 Cleveland Detroyer show?

- Another great substitute would be WIAWSNB from the '72 Long Beach board tape.

- Also, The Lemon Song from 4/27 was still being played under its original title of Killing Floor. Just a point of semantics.

good suggestions although, I hated the Southampton show, not the playing really just the mixing, it sounds flat as Kansas. Plant was off to. your right about WS into kashmir, sadly i don't have those '73 shows you mentioned so i don't know..and nice point out of the lemon song

[kashmiran]

1.Rock and Roll (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)*

2.Black Dog (August 7, 1971- Montreux)**

4.Celebration Day (July 1973- MSG)

5.Train Kept A Rollin’ (June 29, 1980- Zurich)

6.Nobody's Fault But Mine (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

6.Over The Hills And Far Away (March 16, 1973- Vienna)**

7.Misty Mountain Hop (October 9, 1972- Osaka)

8.Dancing Days (June 27, 1972- Long Beach)

Disc 2

1.In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

3.Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

4.Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

5.Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

6.Since I've Been Loving You (March 21, 1975- Seattle)

7.No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8.Song Remains the Same (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

9.The Rain Song (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 3

1.Sick Again (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3.Trampled Underfoot (May 25, 1975- Earl's Court)

4.Moby Dick (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

5.Dazed and Confused (July 1973- MSG)**

6.Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

7.White Summer (August 4, 1979- Knebworth) Into Kashmir (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

8.In The Evening (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 4

1.Stairway to Heaven (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.Whole Lotta Love (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

3.Heartbreaker (March 7, 1970- Montreux)**

4.The Ocean (July 29, 1973- MSG)

5.Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

*Any other suggestions...

**other choices

1.black dog (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

2.Over The Hills And Far Away (June 25, 1972)

3.Dazed and Confused (May 24, 1975- Earls court)

4.Heartbreaker (June 27, 1972- Long beach..

All I have to say is: good taste in specific performances. FYI: Solar's point about WS/Kashmir is invalid because we're talking about a n official, Page-mixed live album, and I'm sure he'd be well capable of blending the two from different years. The biggest conflict here would be the way they were performed between years, generally Page segued into Kashmir at about the 5:20 mark or so, but the earlier verdsions were extended past that and generally made it to about 8-11 minutes. No big problem though, just cut it off early to segue into Kashmir. PS: Generally, I'm really not a huge fan of the WS/Kashmir segue. It just never really seems to cohere well to me. I think WS is better on it's own, preferably in the acoustic set somewhere.

I hated the Southampton show, not the playing really just the mixing, it sounds flat as Kansas. Plant was off too. your right about WS into kashmir, sadly i don't have those '73 shows you mentioned so i don't know..and nice point out of the lemon song

I mixed my own copy of Southamton University, 1973. I split my original recording into multi-tracks, then re-mixed it myself.

[jimmy page66]

I mixed my own copy of Southamton University, 1973. I split my original recording into multi-tracks, then re-mixed it myself.

nice because it sounds soo flat otherwise

[kashmiran]

IT JUST KEEPS GETTING BETTER AND BETTER!!!!!!

Disc 1:

1. Rock and Roll (August 4, 1975 - Knebworth, England)

2. The Rover/Sick Again (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

3. Over the Hills and Far Away (March 19th, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

4. The Song Remains the Same (January 22, 1973 - Southampton University, England)

5. The Rain Song (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

6. Kashmir (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

7. Since I've Been Loving You/Tea For One (July 7, 1980 - Berlin, Germany)

8. No Quarter (Mix between April 27, 1977 & March 19, 1975 - Cleveland, Ohio & Vancouver, Canada)

Disc 2:

1. What is and What and What Never Be (June 27, 1972 - Long Beach Arena)

2. Ten Years Gone (April 28, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

3. Trampled Under Foot (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

4. That's the Way (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

5. Going to California (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

6. White Summer/Black Mountain Side (January 9, 1970 - Royal Albert Hall)

7. The Battle of Evermore (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

8. Moby Dick (Mix between April 28, 1977 & March 20, 1975 - Cleveland, Ohio & Vancouver, Canada)

Disc 3:

1. Achilles Last Stand (June 30, 1980 - Frankfurt, Germany)*

2. Nobody's Fault But Mine (August 4, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

3. In the Evening (August 4, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

4. All My Love (June 21, 1980 - Rotterdam, Netherlands)

5. Stairway to Heaven (Mix between May 24 & 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

6. Whole Lotta Love (August 11, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

7. Louie Louie (July 25, 1972 - LA Forum, California)

8. Organ Solo (July 25, 1972 - LA Forum, California)

9. Thank You (July 25, 1972 - LA Forum, California)

10. Heartbreaker (June 21, 1980 - Rotterdam, Netherlands)

11. Communication Breakdown (July 25, 1972 - LA Forum, California)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

No more "Dazed" or "Whole Lotta Love/The Crunge/Black Dog" medleys, but I managed to squeeze in some more songs without them.

PS - The version of WLL from the 11th at Knebworth is not a typo--I really do prefer that version (having just heard it 10 minutes ago).

* ALS would have the guitar solo from August 4th at Knebworth, but that would be the only modification to this song. Everything else about it would be unadulterated.

[jimmy page66]

This tread owns!

1.Rock and Roll (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.Black Dog (August 7, 1971- Montreux)

4.Celebration Day (July 1973- MSG)

5.Train Kept A Rollin’ (June 29, 1980- Zurich)

6.Nobody's Fault But Mine (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

6.Over The Hills And Far Away (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

7.Misty Mountain Hop (October 9, 1972- Osaka)

8.Dancing Days (June 27, 1972- Long Beach)

Disc 2

1.In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

3.Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

4.Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

5.What is and What Should Never Be (June 27, 1972 Long Beach)

6.Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

7.Since I've Been Loving You (March 21, 1975- Seattle)

8.No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

9.Song Remains the Same (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

10.The Rain Song (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 3

1.Sick Again (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3.Trampled Underfoot (May 25, 1975- Earl's Court)

4.Moby Dick (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

5.Dazed and Confused (July 1973- MSG)

6.Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

7.White Summer (June 21, 1977- LA Forum) Into Kashmir (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

8.In The Evening (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 4

1.Stairway to Heaven (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

2.Whole Lotta Love (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

3.Heartbreaker (March 7, 1970- Montreux)

4.The Ocean (July 29, 1973- MSG)

5.Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

6.Thank You (March 7, 1970 Montreux)

[kashmiran]

Disc 1:

1. Rock and Roll (August 4, 1975 - Knebworth, England)

2. Sick Again (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

3. Over the Hills and Far Away (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

4. The Song Remains the Same (January 22, 1973 - Southampton University, England)

5. The Rain Song (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

6. Kashmir (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

7. Since I've Been Loving You/Tea For One (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

8. No Quarter (Whatever date the one on Badgeholders is from...too lazy to look it up of course)

Disc 2:

1. What is and What and What Never Be (June 27, 1972 - Long Beach Arena)

2. Ten Years Gone (April 28, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

3. Trampled Under Foot (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

4. That's the Way (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

5. Going to California (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

6. White Summer/Black Mountain Side (January 9, 1970 - Royal Albert Hall)

7. The Battle of Evermore (April 27, 1977 - Cleveland, Ohio)

8. Moby Dick (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)

Disc 3:

1. Achilles Last Stand (June 30, 1980 - Frankfurt, Germany)

2. Nobody's Fault But Mine (August 4, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

3. In the Evening (August 4, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

4. Dazed and Confused (March 19, 1975 - Vancouver, Canada)*

5. Stairway to Heaven (Mix between May 24 & 25, 1975 - Earl's Court, England)

6. Whole Lotta Love (August 11, 1979 - Knebworth, England)

7. Organ Solo/Thank You (July 25, 1972 - LA Forum, California)

* Might have to be cut a little...maybe some of the violin bow section? It's a bit long and on the rambling side.

[marmorek]

Imagine: You've just won a contest to have Jimmy Page make you your own live album with your supervision. Any tracks from any date, any venue.

Any date? Any venue? Okay ...

Deer Lake Park

Burnaby, BC

July 5, 2008 (give at least a week to prepare for this monumental event!)

This is the venue (it's just east of Vancouver):

Photos (not mine) are from The Arcade Fire's May 24, 2007 show.

Any tracks? Okay ...

Rock and Roll

Immigrant Song

What Is And What Should Never Be

The Lemon Song

Trampled Under Foot

Black Dog

The Song Remains The Same

The Rain Song

Over The Hills And Far Away

Tangerine

Going To California

Ten Years Gone

Battle of Evermore (w/ Alison Krauss?)

Babe I'm Gonna Leave You

In My Time Of Dying

No Quarter

Since I've Been Loving You

Dazed and Confused

Achilles Last Stand

White Summer > Kashmir

(encore)

Whole Lotta Love (Medley)

Heartbreaker

Communication Breakdown

Bring It On Home

(encore 2)

When The Levee Breaks

Travelling Riverside Blues

Thank You

(encore 3)

Stairway To Heaven

This is a quick setlist, I'd love to hear any suggestions.

For the recording, I'd have Martin Scorsese direct a concert film for theatres and IMAX à la Shine A Light. Soundtrack on iTunes, CD and vinyl. Film released later on DVD and BluRay with 5.1 surround sound.

[jimmy page66]

Check it!

Disc 1

1.Train Kept A Rollin’ (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

2.Celebration Day (July 1973- MSG)

3.Nobody's Fault But Mine Hop (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

4.Black Dog (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

5.Over The Hills And Far Away (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

6.Misty Mountain Hop (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

7.Dancing Days (June 27, 1972- Long Beach)

8.In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

Disc 2

1.The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

2.Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

3.What is and What Should Never Be (January 9, 1970 Royal Albert Hall)

4.Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

5.Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

6.Since I've Been Loving You (March 21, 1975- Seattle)

7.No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8.Song Remains the Same (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

9.The Rain Song (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 3

1.Sick Again (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3.Trampled Underfoot (May 25, 1975- Earl's Court)

4.Moby Dick (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

5.Dazed and Confused (July 1973- MSG)

6.Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

7.White Summer (January 9, 1970 Royal Albert Hall) Into

8.Kashmir (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

Disc 4

1.In The Evening (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.Stairway to Heaven (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

3.Rock And Roll (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

4.Heartbreaker (March 7, 1970- Montreux)

5.Whole Lotta Love (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

6.Communication Breakdown (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

7.The Ocean (July, 1973- MSG)

edited

[Dirigible]

If you ask me, the better and bigger challenge is to compile all these songs into a chronological order, the way Jimmy Page had intended to do years ago. That's how I did mine. I personally don't like starting the set with a song from '80 and finishing with something from '69 for that reason.

C'mon, guys, let's do this up RIGHT.

Instead of one unwieldy supershow why not a 9 show box set of magic nights in chronological order? Why 9? One to represent each year the band toured, 9 out of their 12 years together. Led Zeppelin didn't tour in 1974, 1976 or 1978. My niece has a box set of Buffy, about 40 DVDs arranged in a container the size of four thick paperbacks wedged together so this idea is feasibly packageable. A 26-CD live Zeppelin box set could be done this way: one disk for 1968, two for '69 and for '80, and three disks for years '70 through '79. Encore variations and rarely played tunes could be added to the CDs from their respective year (with proper annotation, of course.)

Or even better! Howzabout setting up an ongoing series like the Grateful Dead's Dick's Picks or Bear's Choices but with LZ instead? There's already 36 Dick's Picks ranging from 2 to 4 CD sets; they've been coming out almost as regularly as magazines for years. If Jimmy would kindly turn the Zeppelin archives over to me I will get right on that, gentlemen.

[kashmiran]

C'mon, guys, let's do this up RIGHT.

Instead of one unwieldy supershow why not a 9 show box set of magic nights in chronological order? Why 9? One to represent each year the band toured, 9 out of their 12 years together. Led Zeppelin didn't tour in 1974, 1976 or 1978. My niece has a box set of Buffy, about 40 DVDs arranged in a container the size of four thick paperbacks wedged together so this idea is feasibly packageable. A 26-CD live Zeppelin box set could be done this way: one disk for 1968, two for '69 and for '80, and three disks for years '70 through '79. Encore variations and rarely played tunes could be added to the CDs from their respective year (with proper annotation, of course.)

Or even better! Howzabout setting up an ongoing series like the Grateful Dead's Dick's Picks or Bear's Choices but with LZ instead? There's already 36 Dick's Picks ranging from 2 to 4 CD sets; they've been coming out almost as regularly as magazines for years. If Jimmy would kindly turn the Zeppelin archives over to me I will get right on that, gentlemen.

Smart suggestion. OK, then:

1968 - Stockholm, Sweden

1969 - Fillmore West (Any)

1970 - Royal Albert Hall (complete!)

1971 - Paris Theater (BBC Sessions)

1972 - Sydney Showground

1973 - Madison Square Garden (28th or 29th)

1975 - Vancouver (19th)

1975 (2) - Earl's Court (25th, but with Stairway from 24th)

1977 - LA Forum (Listen To This Eddie)

1979 - Knebworth (4th)

1980 - Rotterdam

Too lazy to look up the dates right now

[Dirigible]

1968 - Stockholm, Sweden

1969 - Fillmore West (Any)

1970 - Royal Albert Hall (complete!)

1971 - Paris Theater (BBC Sessions)

1972 - Sydney Showground

1973 - Madison Square Garden (28th or 29th)

1975 - Vancouver (19th)

1975 (2) - Earl's Court (25th, but with Stairway from 24th)

1977 - LA Forum (Listen To This Eddie)

1979 - Knebworth (4th)

1980 - Rotterdam

Even girls have those shows in their collections! Everybody's heard those, what do we need them remastered for? How about some whack shit like Offenbach 3-24-73 or St. Louis 2-16-75?

[kashmiran]

I just chose what I thought to be the best. Yes, everyone has them, but a fully-mixed version done by Page himself? A definite set of MUST-HAVES.

[Dirigible]

If I could really paw through the annals of Zep's live history I'd keep tabs on what we zepileptics have readily available via Internet or trading----and definitely opt for the road not taken, to quote Robert Frost.

We've all heard more March 1973 shows than March 1971 shows. "Jimmy, d'yer really have all the small hall tour soundboards?" "They're in there somewhere, Dirigible . . ."

Doesn't everyone think it amazing that Zeppelin recorded four studio albums in their first two and a half years together in addition to performing over 200 concerts internationally? Never mind writing and recording and performing; just traveling to all those shows would've jetlagged my ass out.

[jimmy page66]

Even girls have those shows in their collections! Everybody's heard those, what do we need them remastered for? How about some whack shit like Offenbach 3-24-73 or St. Louis 2-16-75?

I'm sorry i don't have hundreds of bootlegs...

[Dirigible]

I'm sorry i don't have hundreds of bootlegs...

Goddam, 66, I'd've thought with all your authoritative posts you did. I could've sworn you were a dude. Kiddin' yer, mate.

[jimmy page66]

1969 - Fillmore West 27th

1970 - Royal Albert Hall (complete) or Montreux March 7th

1971 - Montreux 8-7

1972 - October 9th Japan or June 25th LA

1973 - Vienna March 16th

1975 - MSG February 14th or 12th

1975 - Earl's Court 24th But encores from the 25th

1977 - June 21,LA Forum

1979 - Knebworth 4th

1980 - Frankfurt

[jimmy page66]

Disc 1

1.The Song Remains The Same (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

2.Celebration Day (July 1973- MSG)

3.Nobody's Fault But Mine Hop (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

4.Black Dog (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

5.Over The Hills And Far Away (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

6.Misty Mountain Hop (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

7.Dancing Days (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

8.In My Time Of Dying (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

Disc 2

1.The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 - LA forum)

2.Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp (May 25, 1975 - Earl's Court)

3.White Summer (January 9, 1970 Royal Albert Hall)

4.What is and What Should Never Be (January 9, 1970 Royal Albert Hall)

5.The Rain Song (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

6.Tangerine (May 24, 1975 - Earl's Court)

7.Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

8.Since I've Been Loving You (September 4, 1970- LA Forum)

9.No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

Disc 3

1.Sick Again (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.Killing Floor (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3.Trampled Underfoot (May 25, 1975- Earl's Court)

4.Moby Dick (June 21, 1977- LA forum)

5.Dazed and Confused (July 1973- MSG)

6.Achilles Last Stand (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

7.Kashmir (February 12, 1975- NYC)

Disc 4

1.In The Evening (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.Stairway to Heaven (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

3.Rock And Roll (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

4.Heartbreaker (March 7, 1970- Montreux)

5.Whole Lotta Love (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

6.Stand By Me (October 9, 1972- Japan)

7.The Ocean (July, 1973- MSG)

8.Long Tall Sally (January 9, 1970- Royal Albert Hall)

9.Communication Breakdown (June 25, 1972- LA Forum)

[jimmy page66]

1969 - Fillmore West 27th

1970 - Royal Albert Hall (complete) or Montreux March 7th

1971 - Montreux 8-7

1972 - October 9th Japan or June 25th LA

1973 - Vienna March 16th

1975 - Vancouver 19th

1975 - Earl's Court 24th But encores from the 25th

1977 - June 21,LA Forum

1979 - Knebworth 4th

1980 - Frankfurt

[jimmy page66]

Disc 1

1.Rock And Roll (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

2.Celebration Day (July 1973 MSG)

3.Nobody's Fault But Mine Hop (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

4.Black Dog (March 16, 1973 Vienna)

5.Over The Hills And Far Away (March 16, 1973 Vienna)

6.Misty Mountain Hop (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

7.Dancing Days (January 22, 1973 Southampton)

8.In My Time Of Dying (March 19, 1975 Vancouver)

Disc 2

1.The Battle Of Evermore (June 21, 1977 LA forum)

2.Going To California (May 25, 1975 Earls Court)

3.Black Country Woman (June 23, 1977 LA Forum)

4.Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp (May 25, 1975 Earls Court)

5.Song Remains The Same (June 21, 1977 LA Forum)

6.The Rain Song (Mix between March 19, 1975 Vancouver & August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

7.Tangerine (May 24, 1975 Earls Court)

8.Ten Years Gone (June 21, 1977- LA Forum)

9.Since I've Been Loving You (September 4, 1970- LA Forum)

10.No Quarter (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

Disc 3

1.Sick Again (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.The Lemon Song (April 27, 1969- Fillmore West Collage)

3.Trampled Underfoot (Mix between May 24, 1975 Earls Court & May 25, 1975 Earls Court )

4.Moby Dick (March 19, 1975 Vancouver)

5.Dazed and Confused (March 19, 1975 Vancouver) OR (March 16, 1973 Vienna)

6.Achilles Last Stand (June 23, 1977 LA Forum)

7.White Summer (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

8.Kashmir (August 4, 1979 Knebworth)

Disc 4

1.In The Evening (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

2.Stairway to Heaven (May 24, 1975- Earl's Court)

3.Whole Lotta Love (August 4, 1979- Knebworth)

4.Heartbreaker (March 16, 1973- Vienna)

5.Communication Breakdown (May 25, 1975 Earls Court)

[greenman]

Just random tracks would not IMHO bring the best out of the band, I'd either stick to entire concerts or pick the best from a show and have them on one disk each.

If I was going to come up with the 4cd release I thought would be viewed as the "best" by the typical fan I might go with the complete Raleigh 7/7/70 and LA 21/8/71 shows. Maybe not as many unique performances as some other concerts but the energy and professionalism is very high thoughout both of them and the setlists are very different. The classic 29/9/71 show with the versions of WLL from 23/9 and 24/9 on a bonus disk would be pretty amazing aswell.

[jimmy page66]

Just random tracks would not IMHO bring the best out of the band, I'd either stick to entire concerts or pick the best from a show and have them on one disk each.

If I was going to come up with the 4cd release I thought would be viewed as the "best" by the typical fan I might go with the complete Raleigh 7/7/70 and LA 21/8/71 shows. Maybe not as many unique performances as some other concerts but the energy and professionalism is very high thoughout both of them and the setlists are very different. The classic 29/9/71 show with the versions of WLL from 23/9 and 24/9 on a bonus disk would be pretty amazing aswell.

I disagree 100% on just about everything you said..