Best version of Since I've been loving you

[antoine]

One of my favourite song ! Which version do you prefer ? For me, it is either LZIII or Htwww, but all are great !

Edited July 26, 2015 by antoine

[Sathington Willoughby]

TSRTS with HTWWW a close second.

[Badgeholder Still]

early days - 1973-03-19 Berlin

latter days - 1977-06-23 Los Angeles

[juxtiphi]

Let us not forget 3-24-1973 A great version of SIBLY and an incredible concert all the way round, Dazed is one of the al time greats.

Edited July 27, 2015 by juxtiphi

[cobykruize]

I voted The song remains the same, but the version on How the west was won is also great .

[MCAN]

Original LZ III version first, TSRTS version comes second.

If the Companion audio version is included, I would pick that as #2 but its similarity to the album master may disqualify it in some people's eyes.

[Klape]

For me it's the album version, everything is just so perfect, Bonham , Page , John Paul Jones and Plant are at one of their finest moment IMO.

[Charles J. White]

Unledded

[KellyGirl]

Although I do enjoy the studio version of this song, I have to say being able to see Jimmy Page play this song makes '73 in NYC at MSG the winner.

[Bozoso73]

3/21/70. . Vancouver . . . Still months from being released and still raw and it's delivery very basic in its infancy but Percy's delivery is one of pain and it gives me goosebumps every time

[JohnOsbourne]

I suppose this fits in with NYC 73, but how about Seattle 73?

[rm2551]

Surely the BBC Sessions deserves a mention. Its an amazingly emotional, stripped back, soft and powerful rendition.

[MrMojoRisin67]

Where is BBC Sessions?!?! That one blows every other version out of the water, in my opinion.

[Canadianzepper]

On 15/11/2015 at 9:42 PM, Bozoso73 said:

3/21/70. . Vancouver . . . Still months from being released and still raw and it's delivery very basic in its infancy but Percy's delivery is one of pain and it gives me goosebumps every time

 

You beat me to it, another ZepHead lent me his tape of various live songs, this was on it, it's now on Youtube like everything else.    Though I didn't keep the tape, I played this song over and over and never forgot the performance.  To my luck and surprise I found it on youtube, even though I didn't know the date or location.  

On the youtube version I found it is missing the intro from Plant right before the song in which he introduces it "this is a thing called, Since I've Been Loving you...let's go!"  He must have been in the mood to bring it for this version.  Powerful drumming intro and the most unique singing interpretation from Plant I have heard of the many I have heard.  I agree with you, really showcased how Plant in particular could just go in any direction lyrically at any time.  

 

Edited December 21, 2016 by Canadianzepper
spelling, adding to original

[Canadianzepper]

On 26/07/2015 at 7:44 PM, Badgeholder Still said:

early days - 1973-03-19 Berlin

 

latter days - 1977-06-23 Los Angeles

Ah yes, 1977 for Badgeholders Only?  Maybe the most famous of all live shows.  A concert for 3 hours or so?  Every song extended beyond the originals.  No wonder they loved L.A and vice versa.

[craigled]

Original album version. Simple. But perfect.