Where's My Dying Cough?

[No1ZeppelinFan]

Just played my old Physical Graffiti on Vinyl for the first time in at least 15 years and was shocked that at the end of "In My time of Dying" there was no "Make it my dying dying.......cough" comment? Should be there shouldn't it?

I think my LP is an eighties version? Was that only on the original A1 version?

[feather in the wind]

it's on all of the vinyl. i have it as well. it's like a flub, made out to be a amusing.

just the 'plane' "ya leave it ya"

[Stargroves Tangie]

Just played my old Physical Graffiti on Vinyl for the first time in at least 15 years and was shocked that at the end of "In My time of Dying" there was no "Make it my dying dying.......cough" comment? Should be there shouldn't it?

I think my LP is an eighties version? Was that only on the original A1 version?

My LP is from '79 and it's on there- however the first cd I had of PG it's not.

[Aquamarine]

it's on all of the vinyl. i have it as well. it's like a flub, made out to be a amusing.

just the 'plane' "ya leave it ya"

I think what he was saying is it's not on his version.

Or she.

[GetTheLedOut]

Just played my old Physical Graffiti on Vinyl for the first time in at least 15 years and was shocked that at the end of "In My time of Dying" there was no "Make it my dying dying.......cough" comment? Should be there shouldn't it?

I think my LP is an eighties version? Was that only on the original A1 version?

As far as I know it's on all the versions. Personally, I love that it's there.

[SteveAJones]

There are variances to fade outs on different pressings through the years. In fact, you'd be surprised how many songs were "snipped" on Led Zeppelin The Definitive Collection (the boxed set released in '90).

[feather in the wind]

oh, i see, interesting, hmm

[DragonOfDarkness]

Just played my old Physical Graffiti on Vinyl for the first time in at least 15 years and was shocked that at the end of "In My time of Dying" there was no "Make it my dying dying.......cough" comment? Should be there shouldn't it?

I think my LP is an eighties version? Was that only on the original A1 version?

Are you sure it's an eighties version? I purchased all my LZ vinyl in the mid-80s and my copy of PG has the entire piece left intact. Right after "...cough" Jimmy noodles some funny lick on his guitar and then it cuts off.

I've listened to the cd version of this song and it feels weird to not have that little gem hanging onto the end of it.

[beatbo]

"....that's gonna be the one..."

all four of my copies have it.

[GetTheLedOut]

Are you sure it's an eighties version? I purchased all my LZ vinyl in the mid-80s and my copy of PG has the entire piece left intact. Right after "...cough" Jimmy noodles some funny lick on his guitar and then it cuts off.

I've listened to the cd version of this song and it feels weird to not have that little gem hanging onto the end of it.

I think they were referring to the version on the first CD releases.

[DragonOfDarkness]

Just played my old Physical Graffiti on Vinyl for the first time in at least 15 years and was shocked that at the end of "In My time of Dying" there was no "Make it my dying dying.......cough" comment? Should be there shouldn't it?

I think my LP is an eighties version? Was that only on the original A1 version?

Pretty sure he was talking about vinyl.

[Evster2012]

Pretty sure he was talking about vinyl.

Worn out a few over the years and never had one missing the studio chatter after IMTOD. 70s, 80s, etc. It's there on all of them. Puzzling.

[No1ZeppelinFan]

Yeah, I mean on vinyl and mine doesnt have it and like some say "It's horrible" when it's not there. I know a lot of the cd's don't have it.

Oh, and I'm a 39 year old Male and proud of it

Edited August 18, 2008 by No1ZeppelinFan

[IanA]

As far as I know, it was only the CD releases from the mid eighties that had the studio chat missing. It was then put right when the 1990 Remasters box set was released.

Worn out a few over the years and never had one missing the studio chatter after IMTOD. 70s, 80s, etc. It's there on all of them. Puzzling.

[No1ZeppelinFan]

I'm really gutted and shocked it's not on my LP. The lp says on the spine

SSK 89400-0 SS2-200 France WE 322

I'm pretty sure I bought this from somewhere like HMV in London's Oxford street in the late eighties?

Edited August 18, 2008 by No1ZeppelinFan

[GetTheLedOut]

I'm really gutted and shocked it's not on my LP. The lp says on the spine

SSK 89400-0 SS2-200 France WE 322

I'm pretty sure I bought this from somewhere like HMV in London's Oxford street in the late eighties?

Very, very odd.

[DragonOfDarkness]

I'm really gutted and shocked it's not on my LP. The lp says on the spine

SSK 89400-0 SS2-200 France WE 322

I'm pretty sure I bought this from somewhere like HMV in London's Oxford street in the late eighties?

I'm assuming that's a Swan Song record. If it is I don't have a clue why that piece is missing. Highly unusual.

[No1ZeppelinFan]

I'm assuming that's a Swan Song record. If it is I don't have a clue why that piece is missing. Highly unusual.

Yeah, Swan Song.

[Levee]

There are variances to fade outs on different pressings through the years. In fact, you'd be surprised how many songs were "snipped" on Led Zeppelin The Definitive Collection (the boxed set released in '90).

Could you site some examples please, then I can compare them to my original vinyl's.

[70sPercy'sPet]

Strange, it is on mine too. "That's gotta be the one, hasn't it?" "Come have a listen then." "Oh, yes, thank you."

[Midnight Rambler]

Just played my old Physical Graffiti on Vinyl for the first time in at least 15 years and was shocked that at the end of "In My time of Dying" there was no "Make it my dying dying.......cough" comment? Should be there shouldn't it?

I think my LP is an eighties version? Was that only on the original A1 version?

I know when it first came out on CD, that part was left off and then they fixed it and put it out with that on it, (within a few weeks, if I remember right). I know because I bought it and then rebought it. So I guess they messed that up on vinyl also. This was 1987.

Edited August 20, 2008 by Midnight Rambler

[dpat]

QUOTE (SteveAJones @ Aug 17 2008, 06:50 PM)

There are variances to fade outs on different pressings through the years. In fact, you'd be surprised how many songs were "snipped" on Led Zeppelin The Definitive Collection (the boxed set released in '90).

Could you site some examples please, then I can compare them to my original vinyl's.

Almost every song that has a fade ... I would imagine there would be too much tape hiss/crackles/noise to fix the fade outs. I'm talking about turning up the volume to hear the complete fade--but be careful when the next tune comes in, it will make you almost jump out of your skin!!

Off the top of my head: Good Times Bad Times, Ramble On, Houses of the Holy, The Rover, Black Dog, Carouselambra ... the list goes on and on.

Being a teenager I would listen to every note Zep played with my headphones cranked and paid close attention to the fade outs. It was disappointing that the fade outs were cut short for the remasters.

Edited August 20, 2008 by dpat

[Ady]

Just played my old Physical Graffiti on Vinyl for the first time in at least 15 years and was shocked that at the end of "In My time of Dying" there was no "Make it my dying dying.......cough" comment? Should be there shouldn't it?

I think my LP is an eighties version? Was that only on the original A1 version?

It was missing from the copy I bought during the eighties as well. I was disappointed as I'd borrowed a copy off a friend a few weeks earlier and it was all intact.

I was pleased when I bought the CD a few years later to find it had been put back.

[Black_Dog_90]

I like the way it ended. I found it interesting. And yes, since it's the original ending, I prefer that way it ended but that's just my opinion.

[comradeshelby]

the copy of my vinyl doesn't have it either.