If Zeppelin tour without Robert...

[Medhb]

Says it all, doesn't it?

No Zeppelin tour. I can deal with that. OK, J's....find that vocalist and get down to business!! Chop, chop! Move along!!

[hot dog]

Says it all, doesn't it?

Of course, Jimmy has principles.

[kirchzep27]

I was listening to -kashmir live75 the other day and was wondering if -jimmy page has written any music inspired by the rain forest. An instrumental album of material by jpj and page would be so interesting. I think that instrumental page did with michael lee at live 8 was so cool and ofcourse jpj's -zooma album and tour was great. In regards to stuff like the live sprawling section of -dazed, wonder how jason would be, stretching like that. At this point and considering the show in 07, they probably wouldnt play that song the way they used to. If they toured... the led zep material would be limited without -robert plant. jpj did great versions of black dog and when the levee breaks live and ofcourse they could play -no quarter. It seems like it would rely mostly on new material, just as a project with -robert plant would.

[SunChild]

I was listening to -kashmir live75 the other day and was wondering if -jimmy page has written any music inspired by the rain forest. An instrumental album of material by jpj and page would be so interesting. I think that instrumental page did with michael lee at live 8 was so cool and ofcourse jpj's -zooma album and tour was great. In regards to stuff like the live sprawling section of -dazed, wonder how jason would be, stretching like that. At this point and considering the show in 07, they probably wouldnt play that song the way they used to. If they toured... the led zep material would be limited without -robert plant. jpj did great versions of black dog and when the levee breaks live and ofcourse they could play -no quarter. It seems like it would rely mostly on new material, just as a project with -robert plant would.

Lovely ideas. Maybe the best of both worlds would be touring with Plant as Zeppelin, and having sections ala the Raising Sand Revue where the others play some nice extended jams while Plant rests his voice prowling the back of the stage? Personally I'd love to hear some musical back and forth between Page, Jones and JB.

[Lee]

If anyone's interested, there's a discussion of this over at the Stones IORR forum. Makes comparisons with the current Queen line-up...

[kiss of fire]

Some of this sounds like what was said at the Mojo awards, if it is all current then it pretty sums up the answer to the zillion dollar question.

Whatever they all do separate or together as long as they are happy and making music that's a good thing.

Time everyone else let them move on.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/sto...tory/WBfilmfest

[leddy]

If anyone's interested, there's a discussion of this over at the Stones IORR forum. Makes comparisons with the current Queen line-up...

How you doing mate ??

[Lee]

How you doing mate ??

Still hanging in there, Leddy!

I went to Knebworth House a couple of weeks ago for the exhibition, and met up with Paul (Ledded1) and Annie who was running it. Ended up standing in the field where they played, trying to figure out where we were in August '79.

Pretty hard to remember after 30 years!

...but it certainly recaptured the vibe standing there with a couple of verterans from back in the day.

[Byljer]

LZ should NOT tour at all without Robert Plant! That would surely kill their legacy for good!

[kdh]

Legacy? Touring would not kill the legacy, maybe tarnish it for those that were to tour w/o Robert

"I am past Led Zeppelin" Plant. I do want to see a tour with Jones, Page, Bonham and the new voice.

[Olipticle]

Hrmm didnt think about it before but an instrumental album with Page, JPJ and Kid jason might be pretty sick. Id honestly buy it regardless but i mean it might allow them to branch out like they want to.

[feather in the wind]

nah, no instrumental, i like stories behind the music i listen to. my opinion.

and 'zeppelin' won't tour without plant becuz THERE IS NO ZEPPELIN WITHOUT PLANT!

i don't like it when a band replaces someone and continues to tour as they were, they are not as 'they were' anymore without that guy they replaced. (unless it's blood i.e. jason, and even then, it was a fine line to call the o2 Led Zeppelin, maybe it should have been Led Zeppelin II or The New Led Zeppelin.........)

i read too many posts, zeppelin's new album, who will zeppelin's new singer be? what will zeppelin's alnum be called?

well robert said 'no', so therefore NO MORE ZEPPELIN! no zeppelin album, no zeppelin new singer.

k, my rant $0.02

[Olipticle]

although i agree that they shouldnt do "zeppelin" without plant, A instrumental Album is better then nothing. I mean i love vocals just like the next bloke. But if all you can get is the guitar, bass and drums them im happy. But there is no quick fix that can be done over vocals, It will either be a hit or terrible miss

[LedZep1969]

although i agree that they shouldnt do "zeppelin" without plant, A instrumental Album is better then nothing. I mean i love vocals just like the next bloke. But if all you can get is the guitar, bass and drums them im happy. But there is no quick fix that can be done over vocals, It will either be a hit or terrible miss

it would be really weird to see zep without their freaking singer

[roundourway]

it would be a hanging offence

[ninelives]

it would be a hanging offence

Well it's not happening so thankfully no hangings will happen

[Coda.S]

Absolutely no one. Any alternative would be a degradation of everything that Led Zeppelin ever was and destroy whatever integrity remains.

Absolutely

[reids]

Immigrant Song

No Quarter

Thank You

tEa For One

Going To California

Rain Song

In My Time of Dying

That's The Way

Your Time Is Gonna Come

R

Edited March 20, 2009 by reids

[bigledzepfan1963]

LZ should NOT tour at all without Robert Plant!

led zeppelin with page,plant,jones ,and JOHN BONHAM,is'nt led zeppelin!!!!!

with jason sitting in for bonzo,it's damn good,but not led zeppelin!!!!!!!!

[Reggie29]

LZ should NOT tour at all without Robert Plant!

led zeppelin with page,plant,jones ,and JOHN BONHAM,is'nt led zeppelin!!!!!

with jason sitting in for bonzo,it's damn good,but not led zeppelin!!!!!!!!

are you talking about?

[Dr Death]

are you talking about?

Maybe he's a Cozy Powell fan?

[bouncing~ship]

Fuck Dio...(not the God...the singer)

It's Robert...or just forget about it

lol...I say...wait a Decade...Im pretty sure they can all pull it off

[glicine]

Why does this thread still exist???

[ninelives]

Why does this thread still exist???

I don't know Just when it dies, a new member comes in and revives it I suppose

[Coda.S]

I don't know Just when it dies, a new member comes in and revives it I suppose

Yea because he's new and wants to reply as the old members did